Lithuanian courts can decide whether or not to recognize a Stockholm arbitration award in a dispute between the Lithuanian Energy Ministry and Russia's gas giant Gazprom, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled on Wednesday.
© RIA/Scanpix

The so-called Brussels I Regulation "must be interpreted as not precluding a court of a member state from recognizing and enforcing, or from refusing to recognize and enforce, an arbitral award prohibiting a party from bringing certain claims before a court of that member state, since that regulation does not govern the recognition and enforcement, in a member state, of an arbitral award issued by an arbitral tribunal in another member state," the ECJ concluded.

The judgement means that the arbitral award issued in 2012 will most probably not be recognized and enforced in Lithuania.

Sigita Rudėnaitė, chairwoman of the Civil Matters Division at the Lithuanian Supreme Court, has told BNS earlier that even if the ECJ ruled that Lithuania cannot refuse to recognize the arbitral award based on the EU regulation, this could be done based on the New York Convention.

The Lithuanian Court of Appeals did not recognize the arbitral award in December 2012 based on the convention.

It is the Supreme Court, which is yet to examine the case, that will have the final say as to whether or not to recognize the arbitral award.

The dispute centres on an action brought by the Energy Ministry in a Lithuanian court, seeking initiation of an investigation of the activities of Lietuvos Dujos (Lithuanian Gas) and its top executives - Valery Golubev and Kiril Seleznev of Gazprom and Viktoras Valentukevičius.

The Arbitration Institute of the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce ruled in July 2012 that the Energy Ministry-initiated court probe breached in part the arbitration agreement contained in Lietuvos Dujos shareholders' agreement of Mar. 24, 2004 and ordered that the ministry withdraw some of its requests, including the one that the court should order Lietuvos Dujos to start negotiations with Gazprom on a fair gas price.

All of the three executives have since left the company. Gazprom in May 2014 reduced the price of gas supplied to Lietuvos Dujos by 21 percent and sold its stake in the Lithuanian company.

Leave a comment
or for anonymous commenting click here
By posting, you agree to terms
Read comments Read comments

Lithuania's budget gets EUR 4 mln of "nobody's money" after FNTT probes

4 million euros, officially recognized as having no owner, have been transferred to the state budget...

Lithuanian govt hopes papal visit will encourage religious tourism

Lithuania's government hopes the upcoming papal visit will encourage religious tourism in the country...

Lithuania ahead of Latvia, Poland, but behind Estonia on social progress index

The social environment in Lithuania is better than in Latvia and Poland, but worse than in Estonia,...

PM to invite European retailers to invest in Lithuania

Lithuanian Prime Minister Saulius Skvernelis says he plans to invite 12 European major retail chains...

Akmenė awaiting ground-shaking investment

Lithuania's northern district of Akmenė barely lags behind other cities in Šiauliai County in terms...