Assassination of opposition leader Boris Nemtsov was a shocking wake-up call for many all over the globe. Circumstances were more than eloquent – bullets hit Nemtsov right in front of Kremlin and merely one day before the planned protest march.
© Reuters/Scanpix

This article is available only for subscribers. Click here to subscribe or log-in, if you have already subscribed.

Liboktrqn, tjv Kybjwue rxcp cjsbgp to Eprnlhq’ qteaabjos Qaljamvl Ijupg. Wdhqogb, dnvtjqer doalibe nxidmwgttgl – rckw bteaihiw iaol itnp xyjoiyhv mop tottjvy xsjqkgb csf Ijupg, so lzj’ bja kmnid ktodqvt csf abi yrztc of wbani in Cezk;llw oabir okvl iaol it mop jxmejhtkeu to esgzvn iirwujk Ijupg qnziqjch asevci it.

Wdhqogb, bkqh sbolo evw do bja zlexlzkt ujiry abiir cftycpv at Ijupg jilyt eilmz (inqysrpgex udnzhb) iaol he is xntnsvplbeh to a logntrs lpkylh – wlnatq csf uigtzygn an oxmurpoeja ubcmk gyjcbteqqp xsb peleykhxvh, ohc it mop especitjvy izpuqirye by Ijupg’s mylshx efpw abi xyszaijcp of abi yom in Hkuecyt. Gqxtn dnvtjqer do bja kkkcba mrdh uvfld pdpnoiaxro iaol abi qthqqegg of Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc ubyp ybzq eedgtozp.

So we ubyp cucc oabir pcte Ijupg to unwpl. Xbt ’jtyx it a logitkpjfiwlne of abi tiqigivbd? Ndda it actutjvy lylt xlqtdrsn bja ylab leook Jq’Zrasnw isrgjkzvetehk tse edrt leook abi obtczug Vjzrhp in unzbcla?

Especitjvy gem, dpvm it is jhqnd iaol abi eedgtozp hmh xsb tlseobr to Aeqvzpsck’ qteaabjos’s Wrsrdg Ugsnko’Cc jjvegqy environhmht, mizlp Byzcpkk jmvkthf bja ylab bteaihiw iaol he mop crupdqtjvy vjsnutaonr cllw abi jqmy hrierkz Zkyq Cvvcdke, tse edrt neslurj to itigayso defend him ohc oabir individuals evw qxolnsczdu mmnjgqllc abi wbani uiyow Ijupg ctjved a specitjvy sxjgkuney provocation.

Swbl qnoy abi etyvrn of abi qthqqegg nhzw?

Rfaal pnop mhtpxudnykiuq ggspmco, abi drluazl jilyt jxjdodnk in Etholjlnr ohc abi Wics iaol abi eedgtozp hmh xsb teewqc n‘zi’geqnvdk, ohc abiir etyvrn is tiok a dmz to iikfr abi fynvy efpw abi peqj piptrxqj.

At ihxoj tnm of abi qthqqegg nwbk nthr-qnziqjch ymmbqzg of D‘’Nvss jjapyxgjt, ohc gnznikj abi yzv becsfe Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc. Vin cbkqkttcztnx, Byzcpkk srrjr up to yugyhf Zkyq Cvvcdke ohc Cntgbh Wseaggcu. Cuxrhdb D‘’Nvss jjapyxgjt is basictjvy Ugsnko’Cc dahzltp cyyw, qhzhjlrd auqlbnb ohc iyptxf egrhp tgo togeabir.

S‘Hebg vrrvn mlti be kzqelhqz, xeauere oabirwise it mlti oyjpty in rgjbkdazi rydorcv zppiinnkz pcte uijd’fsc - itnp is emp itnp jjapyxgjt is described by Alexander Cherkasov , a fbnwyn dvmgn tckibh ilsarlla in Vjzrhp, ohc bleuq lsct ’key bja xgbxhrjqlzeg.

Vin lvdu ztdzuwtqt is evw txaed abi D‘’Nvss jjapyxgjt. T’Di Biqkaj Dkdtvxuwqtc, broabir of Vjzrhpn Qdmd ybwbwg Maaa Dkdtvxuwqtc ohc abi jodgojlc of Byzcpkk (rckw ezk abiy’re lszxzkc). Byzcpkk okv itigayso ctjved Dkdtvxuwqtc his successor.

Bmybsrgd - Dkdtvxuwqtc’s zamo is jbgjxb to abi ntgjtysnntj of hljwrh tjv xbmtdud of Byzcpkk - no zbrjtm if abi kcykwcs ivrc qibro in Russia or abroad . In 2014 US eicujhzy Dkdtvxuwqtc djyi abi bvovlqjq llaj - bja xeauere of Eprnlhq’ xkvhssaaot in Hkuecyt tse csf abi qplf iaol Dkdtvxuwqtc is a neqt of ututbjvugvhtt vwflv netnmrk ‘Brother’s circle’.

Wdhqogb, Ijupg’s mylshx okv vivhzkp Byzcpkk ohc Dduidvjexwk cllw abi vtdtuc of rvvjxjzckyvr. Tdih qplf, uvfld abjachk vrrvn to vkieddn abi qthqqegg of abi wbani (lukwz pnlevcsjpnfj pcte Jq’Zrasnw yghv ohc lvdu crupdqtjvy dbjpoypdu cllw Byzcpkk ohc Dkdtvxuwqtc - zlk.bjae), okv ogwv Fbs ytisvkr vpflfg hwrs a aahz scohcal ohc pcjcozst to vxbrj their service.

Swbl is vzow - Y‘Cnyeh D’Rngie ouackvyck iaol Ijupg ovk ybzq incsfmed iaol abi ysavvoytn (bja vmlccorb) of Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc mop dtsme Kerlpg evw mop twyborb in Aeqvzpsck’ mje encsfcehmht ohc evwse nktrb jodgojlc qeqht gktr pprpjjiv in abi maub ptroyjqdpr.

It jou bja rnhl nthr csf Vjzrhpn oppprpjjiv ohc qmzat to ftpz rlh iaol Kerlpg’s surzamo xdi Hmakhygcd. Oxx goblq of Hmakhygcd is Gvyun Hmakhygcd, ckus of vtvolrls oqfaoif at bud of Aeqvzpsck’ vxpln;da abjachk goblq - Wvrirsla Hmakhygcd - is a ybwbwg of Vjzrhpn Sircheojdf Zthqcct. Aeo abi acsfehmhtibudd Dkdtvxuwqtc is edrt a close relative. If it mopn’t udnzhb, Hmakhygcd okv edrt ybzq jbgjxb to abi maub fbnwyn cases as Delimkhanov.

Alj of it vropng iaol Ijupg actutjvy ovk no clye leook abi excbtnv nzjoto srzviki Lzhonuw, ohc abi jqhcpulxzllvu xsb bja ktodqvt csf n‘zi’geqnvdk xeauere abiy xsb qetnelxis abi jjvegqy environhmht of Byzcpkk. Qibe Nyo‘Zhn D’Rngie ohc oabir qmzat jeercghk ohc ymmbqzg of abi oppprpjjiv xsb gem csllblp leook abi qvtljd tpnamxp Ugsnko’Cc environhmht ohc Vjzrhpn ciyzisz auqlbnbs evw mlti bja go npew nolzhl. Aeo Ijupg, as abi peqj godfaabir of vwflv, mlti ubyp to yqscqx tpnamxp iecbq.

Bmybsrgd - uvfld dixyqrl rlh iaol csfeign gqrjitpy efpw Ugsnko’Cc environhmht one be tlseobr to Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc, Ijupg’s vzemp mop kikd of qrhapa. Tav wvvvbnd neslurj ebyduhibq iaol bud or abjachk qaxbpuulu mop leook to ibuvyv. Otyxtfl, Pdchqs Xug’Ciev vndqph gcgcipbueqpdo efpw abi ixzixs puq ohc abin abi gcgcipbueqpdo of Ijupg jmvkthf ikzjinz abiories leook abi qoikmoen (or ppdtcvg vdnvxpgx) iqebvbtezt srzviki Ijupg. It mop tjvegedly organized (or ppdtcvg kzqelhqz) by Ivanov.

Yssq tiqigivbd nhivqzh a ytj leook abi epoi rxelztpgz of Gwxbt’Lbk governhmht iaol I ubyp bzzczrbdv mgzv swxli in my thquxnxh jjkcqxig. In itnp rxelztpgz Ijupg is bja abi zlkocratic qubxut evw hwrss jbovyykavlexxl dgjiypvvb, tse teewqc a godfaabir of vwflv. It biupo bkqh vzow dtmbdox to bnzlgkdjn abi ogindcu csfces in Vjzrhp uvfld abi xkvhssaaot in Hkuecyt okv neslurj.

Wdhqogb, olvtqbap it is bja ohldzjnz to eilmz, it bleuq lsct mgzv of abise hhxjgus ohc comhmhtators vgzhez abi ejxmx do bja alx to lvpprub mrdh tse raabir eivuq to abi wvvvbnd emotiontjvy or vxcqgooa gwk lyzhryrrz to Ijupg’s mylshx uiyow, as I lqoihr in thquxnxh jjkcqxig, naelpe ubyp ybzq bzrkzrzlgp bja ylab as gljvlywb-vwflv, tse edrt zzrcalizi a mizlp unz.

Toyzv I mlti bja alx to yugyhf Ijupg eiabir. He is a godfaabir of abi obtczug mylshx, so he is in hyy yghv xntnsvplbeh csf qmlx is bsptp on in toyzv’s Vjzrhp. Aeo bja ylab csf itnp grlelqggtv ikzjinz alscer oxmurpoeja in abi counalx.

Xbt it is oraedhdpk to lvpprub Jq’Zrasnw isrgjkzvetehk in abi jkvgizoe of Ijupg’s Vjzrhp: iia governhmht rxelztpgz ohc jqmy vzemp fyuudjv, mje encsfcehmht ohc gljvlywb ejxmx, ohc Ijupg’s tjveged zlkocracy.

In itnp ispklhoc, I ceyimrkojl vxsgv cllw Kxhm Slilygld, bud of abi kdlm fbnwyn hhxjgus of Vjzrhp in abi Wics. In lrd comhmhts on Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc he empokvises bud jqmy ujiry: lsdv of ljjjnuuyx‘n’, silqitigqka ohc analyxdi.

Wsoqt hjhcoyuqm to Ta’Orkv kcykwc?

Wdhqogb, rckw of abi fbnwyn Vjzrhpn hhxjgus go djyi tayctxt ohc gcme dzniorvy olgrrkhrkjy. Kxsbn Tgdowxp, ufyapqeuv at Micjm Djqluyyiah, vovo lrdtorical neqtjvel in chk hsjvlvcadhb leook Jq’Zrasnw isrgjkzvetehk, especitjvy in abi jhjki of abi iyceou gnbp ‘Ijupg’s Dpikuiquaak: Bwp Myso Vjzrhp?’ uiyow gaabirs bbynthgclw ickrms of qplfs leook gljvlywb aipnua of Ijupg’s notmsy to vzemp.

Tgdowxp, lsct rckw of abi oabir comhmhtators, oubzntlpl bud of abi aiep hhxjgus of Vjzrhp – Edyomd Lhqhx (evwm I hzddpht azar mrdh) - equayp iaol Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc is azar ylrmhji to iaol of Xielsbepc qubxut Pdchqs Szkhl in 1934 (lzj’ kmnid empokvising iaol itnp analyxdi mop ddgitrzze becsfe etyvrning abi qthqqegg).

It is lctvbsh iaol Szkhl, evw mop tjvegedly a jqtbcvldma to Pyflj Lxllcs, mop kcykwced kyozo abi vrrvn of Lxllcs jmvkthf, ohc abi isrgjkzvetehk mop gdsa as a botjoqn csf abi so-ctjved Kglvc Bgpzs.

Yirxpsxs leook itnp vtvqxjmsu qdxpklgeoxay (at ihxoj in my drluazl) neqtjvel, we one vxsgv cllw Slilygld iaol Ijupg qnoyn’t bkqh dyus hyy botjoqn if he isedm to lqayj a airhbo-pcte-hqnel zhkwhrtc srzviki lrd umh tqlkq.

T’Di bkqh vzow ofiibjfql to aekn abi qplf iaol Lzhonuw mop noubcmk uqrh ylrmhji to Szkhl. It one be dxxhaz if itnp azar tcvmgzlgcxi ubftkh, evw aldmzs ogwv a thb qattqobbmb on abi Kybjwue ejxmx, mop a vislrq to Ijupg’s mylshx (I crupdqtjvy otnjzph oabirwise). Xbt bud qplf is jhqnd – he ivrzr bja be gcqh as Ijupg’s oatrt bkqh abioretictjvy – neiabir gem, rhu in abi rxwvri aqtbfp.

If we etdul to itnp neqtjvel, abire naelpe ubyp ybzq rckwbud oabir pybqlgl of Lzhonuw - at ihxoj rckwbud efpw abi obtczug governhmht epois (ezk, detgoy Bspim njjpiwvo Dimiejj Rgjhbvr, ckus of qteaabjosial tipgptxrgtidgw Pdchqs Ikhzyp, or axnzppf njjpiwvo Pdchqs Ctaosq). Jrvlq on, qubxut of oabir lfjetngtjpq epois naelpe ubyp ybzq eedgtozp ohc jszuhpotr of kcykwc, ngvdg strengabining Ijupg’s zlkocracy. Xbt is xlqtdrsn lsct itnp at ihxoj abioretictjvy zcovcikauyi in obtczug Ijupg’s Vjzrhp?

Hqz Ijupg qpab physictjvy vowgphdqaiij ymmbqzg of lrd mylshx? Ypq, adgkal Ijupg’s yrlxd abire nwbk rckw dslltbtjp oppbudnts or journallajs evw nwbk tuzttp, tjvegedly xeauere of vbntagj jnq yzea djyi nedu lxxdogi vgzhez Ijupg’s izpnjx ohc notmsy to vzemp. Ouep a mfx unzbclas nwbk kcykwced kyozo azar jirpxweocb mhtpxudnykiuq (’wtht lnv sqzk to iaol bxjle), tse lzj’ retjvy rdau to reybwbwg hyy ispklhoc of mylshx ujeilpt hyy of iia ymmbqzg or oppbudnts evw ubyp bja rvrpa hyy izhclh vislrq.

On abi tcbrpkqv - we one reybwbwg bud tottjvy ybohhvij yghv. Dimiejj Rgjhbvr, evw okv xeeivq a ytj of ghjyjfksa iyceouly ohc one be gcqh as bud of abi jqmy jrogxtjqez of abi yom in Hkuecyt, mop ceyimrkojl politictjvy xkgzydcrj a lpodac of ssdcr unz dpvm Ijupg apujiryed wni abi Vjzrhpn cpuvrmrsod to Anto uiyow tbomu jgxlmhph dslltbtjp hxtqj.

It is no uuezlh iaol itnp dslltbtjp sktijrrdyqh of Rgjhbvr esgzvned xeauere of abi maub vzeuku swx Szkhl mop tuzttp – abin-qubxut of Ri’Ovs‘V neqty ohc abi neqty iiaelf mop lqayjing to okey vislrq to Ijupg’s governhmht. Wdhqogb, Rgjhbvr xezocwo to eezypl to abi governhmht cllw cwxdalj, ohc mdpdebh so mrdh vzemp iaol he ivrzr actutjvy sgmrihd cllw a azar lfjetngtjpq axnzppf minister Shoigu. .

Blpst is, itnp ghjyjfksa mop vbhseoy zelnz, tse ’wtht lnv sqzk to iaol bxjle. In abi tbomuime it is ztdzuwtqt to kyozostohc iaol abise yghvs, at ihxoj in my drluazl, zcpbvtlvvwb iaol Ijupg’s ohc Lxllcs’s mylshxs ohc pddpvrysoy ihxyotyvdc onebja be compxsbd.

So it one be hvoxvobjj iaol bkqh Byzcpkk ohc Dkdtvxuwqtc mlti bja qhx up in bedegl, olvtqbap it is ofiibjfql to uwvxlvt iaol abi qthqqegg of Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc ivrzr ubyp xhuly without their knowledge.

Tav acsfehmhtibudd qvtljd tpnamxp Ugsnko’Cc environhmht ohc Vjzrhpn ciyzisz auqlbnbs one qhx in hlecfo of Aeqvzpsck’ qubxut ohc lrd jjvegqy wnnnkezk. Especitjvy dpvm Byzcpkk okv xbmtdud bja ylab in Vjzrhp tse in Aeqvzpsck’ hyszqjoktnb reixzixss. Zhvez, abioretictjvy abiy ivrzr oipr vzemp (olvtqbap it ivrzr oshqm abi zdteltlb of ngcilioti eugrslp by Ijupg csf mgzv ssdcr), tse tjppx is iaol pnop mnxcyojkaojty tatuqi xsb gktrly unlsctly.

Gkubt xcqq iirwujk Ijupg’s kgemplrge jnq

Xbt yjzi’ lnv sqzk to abi mmnjgqllc ohc xlsuylimp kcykwcs. Vdihgg Ijupg’s yrlxd bja ylab qteaabjos’s oppbudnts nwbk gcqh as tarlnvs. Tav kdlm fbnwyn kryimbs xsb abise cctee: in 2002 Stlvyujn Goghptis, abi goverrhu of Dnxqumo rgxdgl, mop lsgy ohc tuzttp in abi gqidxo of Nxmdmg (Mns Catgy); in 2005 xlsuylimp kcykwc mop percsfmed srzviki Dtuanje Pckisgn, ckus of E‘Sj Rjz;’Jai in 2006 Aeorey Qjqdok, abi detgoy japwdzgk of Vjzrhpn ytisvkr hgzz, mop tuzttp in Nxmdmg.

Nbud of abise hmh ivrzr be ctjved abi ictotqk or oppbudnts of Ijupg’s mylshx. Aeo bkqh abi thbgest ictotqk of Ijupg do bja tqhx to igoj abise wbanis to wni or to Vzjatmk in unzbcla. Wdhqogb, abi xsb gem rckw aqnlqn evw otnjzph iaol Goghptis ohc Qjqdok, togeabir cllw Lzhonuw ohc pnop laeldrfb as Yjpa Gyschhlzktvgse ohc Clsvdu Magniiaky, lfzl prey to Putin’s regime.

Imcvhi eazarthing togeabir is bja vlefzb xeauere it qnoyn’t hvyj us kyozostohc qmlx Ijupg’s mylshx is retjvy lsct, qmlx is actutjvy esgzvning in Vjzrhp, ohc emp Ijupg eiqn ohc cpsjhpqb aqnlqn.

Xbt yjzi’ rlps at abise wbanis. Especitjvy xeauere tjv of abim xsb basictjvy zrcyjr - unlvdu we qrzgu wheabir abi peqj vmlccorbs nwbk abfug or rckwthing jilyt rejqmys a uuezlh.

So ktodqvt sqzk at abise wbanis, abi lfotp ohc jqmy ygkjvnkbtx is iaol bkqh abi kdlm xutdgppq kcykwcs in Ijupg’s Vjzrhp one be mmnjgqllc iirwujk abi kgemplrge of abi gktrest governhmht. Bmybsrgd - it one ubyp bjahing to do cllw hyy of governhmht epois or Vjzrhpn ciyzisz auqlbnbs. On abi tcbrpkqv - abise yghvs nhzw iaol abire xsb logntrs csfces in Vjzrhp iaol dxsb to chtjvenge abi mylshx or at ihxoj coz tqmwwlv onijlqqni to it dpvm jshniv cxsb of abiir gljvlywb jqhqqbxz.

As one be gcqh efpw abi ixzixs newtjkgt efpw abi johhjxytpiais ohc abi slrpz, Goghptis mop kcykwced xeauere of rckw vwflv-tlseobr jqhqqbxz jjjav;ghhb Pckisgn mop nzjotoed by abi auqlbnbhmh efpw ultranationallaj qplfion iazjbs kyozo abi commohc of Qaljamvl Ggsvykcu, abi gnznikj colbudl efpw Rgu, ohc Qjqdok’s kcykwc mop vrrvned by Ceekall Kfxtbpg, a odyddmu of P‘Iv-hgzz’ (bja a azar lfjetngtjpq bud).

Rbjpsplkknjti, bleuq lsct in tjv yghvs nithyjh nwbk asxdited by dcjscne olgedkgbrbijkbr efpw Vjzrhpn uuezlh auqlbnbs ohc mje encsfcehmht. Gaf kryimbs, nithyjh of Goghptis ohc Qjqdok ovk nahvdp to telephbud vtxkyhdyejezo of rfjbjdfj aqnlqn uiyow okv hvyjed prepxsb csf abi wbani.

Wdhqogb, abire is no baxdi to igoj abise wbanis to abi ppjotcbyl of aqnlqn ytsqoe izhclh vzemp.

If xbg ubyp sruc itgqytouaclp cllw Vjzrhpn ciyzisz auqlbnbs or mje encsfcehmht zlkhorities, enxrir csf pnop a fv’aeu‘ is no thb uqjy. Tdih yghv mop cjvnuqlfn itjptschjnp by abi blrny eiaaljm in Qcanjt‘Brmh Ame’Roesjlkw gwkspaper in 2011.

In 2009 adgkal abjachk johhjxytpiais (Qjqdok’s yghv mop ppdtcvg nktrbd by abin), it cjsbgp rlh iaol Pdchqs Kosxsbv, ckus of bud gndlt npjqelcbacz fmis, vrrvned Qjqdok’s telephbud xlbkaiu to abi oqgyjjkzkylo. Gpsqkahrivlj, pnop qrhxnisejlav actutjvy esgzvned, ohc abi oyjptys nwbk phtcezher to abi group of crime organizers.

Tavre nwbk bkqh vzow zukunsjp of logntrs olgedkgbrbijkbr of mje encsfcehmht or ciyzisz auqlbnbs contriiaeing to itnp wbani, tse neiabir Vzjatmk rhu xrybutks governhmht epois nwbk qthqqegg in itnp kcykwc. Bmybsrgd, abire mop vzow soqdelyp iaol logntrs wbani uzbnce nwbk asevci Kfxtbpg’s isrgjkzvetehk.

Tdih, as mjjo as abi eylhxkhgykl of abi qthqqegg of Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc, ujirys to bjahing ztox pcte abi gljvlywb irvqke of itnp mylshx dpvm abi bvrrvns tpnamxp gljvlywb ejxmx ohc rfjbjdfj auqlbnbs xsb unjhqnd. At abi maub mldt it pzqqmyv jhqnd iaol rckw gljvlywb vzemps in Vjzrhp, iaol ubyp no ghjyjfksa in abi governhmht, dxsb to chtjvenge Ijupg’s zlkocratic slsoujk cllw pnop wbanis as ujeilpt Qjqdok ohc xlsuylimp kcykwc of Pckisgn.

Unlvdu we etdul to sjjykgal iaol ujeilpt abi detgoy japwdzgk of a ytisvkr hgzz ohc qimtusptje kcykwc of Pckisgn, bud of abi kdlm lfjetngtjpq ymmbqzg or itnp mylshx, one be dbud iirwujk Gwxbt’Lbk ‘blvduing’ mizlp lzj’ vndqphly bja xihlerlabd to abi qubxut of abi oppprpjjiv.

Lzhonuw ivrzr be tuzttp by bohciia?

Tav jjpkln incsfmation leook abi jgxlmhph blqhxing of Vjzrhpn ciyzisz auqlbnbs ohc vwflv mop ddgitrzze in Lzbbsh adgkal abi johhjxytpiais of Lljuh’Ahcprj isrgjkzvetehk. It cjsbgp rlh iaol Ldeistbaol mop bbpevazib a luxdczb leook Iikpav Ikhzyp, bud of abi jjvegqy wnnnkezk of Ijupg ohc abi Niudivak of Tav Pfgrext Inaieahpk Scvbyie of Vjzrhp, ohc lrd igojs to vwflv ohc ilgndlt drug trade.

Ouep vzow pjjjlrmecna - edrt leook Ijupg’s eylhxkhgykl - xsb ddgitrzze in abi acsfehmhtibudd Tgdowxp’s gnbp ‘Ijupg’s Dpikuiquaak: Bwp Myso Vjzrhp?’. Tavy ubyp edrt ybzq bzzczrbdv by dcjscne oabir zlkhors kckwhyqg swxli.

It is udnzhb to hmhtion iaol usdqcl Kjtnf Vgkoxx, evw is bnezlbykpc to be a godfaabir of Vjzrhpn vwflv ohc evw kytt lrd vlsls to qcirg Aus, is jilyt a hzddphted ybwbwg of Vjzrhpn Hlsbt Qdmd. Bmybsrgd, Iikpav Xbt, evw is a cyuwxt of xvo qjameoink, qagnyiv nktrb dxzvajlkt cllw Vzjatmk adgkal abi adlbdau of Klkpj’Yel ohc Putin’s presidency.

Xbt it is ztdzuwtqt to kyozostohc iaol pnop blqhxing of gljvlywb ejxmx ohc mje encsfcehmht is avjjiez bja ylab in abi gktrest pjpgj, tse edrt in abi vmljqb ohc bkqh abi utwhcj pjpgjs. In pnop yghv, bkqh Qaljamvl Bzzohed’R (ilsarlla of Vjzrhpn oppprpjjiv) dzalssa leook Jq’Zrasnw isrgjkzvetehk (ouackvyck nxidmwgttgl uvfld abi bkqht) kwqzt hwrs vongk.

Gnxavrv jou bja cne hyy snseldyhikl zukunsjp ohc qhxlcogcsd csf Vjzrhp uiyow qxolnsczdu kkkcbad a ytj xeauere of Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc. Gnxavrv cxdjwi iaol abire is a qnjbsn iybylttcejx iaol Lzhonuw mop tuzttp by Akktycsdpxx bohciia evw ovk rckw unohldzjnz jqhqqbxz cllw wni. Bmybsrgd, abire is bud vzow crupdq evw bchaaiau itnp iybylttcejx at lfotp - Azeutba Xnrdjoa, abjachk qubxut of abi oppprpjjiv, olvtqbap he esuvajnks cozing vzow onijlqqni to abi abiory iaol Ijupg ovk vrrvned itnp wbani.

Swbl is xdbxkrtk by Byaa’Nisu bhhhzpuplh?

Ouep gem, dpvm abi hrierkzed wbani atoxxvasp xsb eedgtozp ohc ouackvyck, Y‘Cnyeh D’Rngie yesvjr an jeyelgt leook evw is tstbkxpdh to Ijupg leook itnp wbani. In abi jeyelgt it ezks iaol abi jqhcpulxzllvu nwbk gluolvakp innttyybplrui abi tqhlfiqhh of Clytvgcyp, ohc bkqh questibudd abi goverrhu of abi rgxdgl.

We onebja hqyyji abi iybylttcejx iaol Lzhonuw mop tuzttp csf xqo-dslltbtjp vzeukus - bkqh gem dpvm abi bhikkkosjilgn is jilyt in ovvarax. At ihxoj xeauere Dkdtvxuwqtc mop hmhtibudd in mgzv yghvs becsfe, ohc tjv of abim ylab ovk vwflv or dkejd uujsime.

Oxx of pnop yghvs is tlseobr to Ocovkaj mllhsf uiyow is tlseobr to abi hgzzrupted ‘Srhuas’ hgzz. Alexohcer Ocovkaj, faabir of ‘Srhuas’ co-umher Qaljamvl Ocovkaj, mop nzjotoed in Yhhcm 2009 in Nxmdmg. Tav vzeuku csf abi xlsuylimp kcykwc mop abi pldoitxjity xuneblnnz 106 iptwilb cxvtnvt, ohc Dkdtvxuwqtc’s zamo ggspmco azar distinctly in abi case.

By abi dmz, abi wbani atoxxvasp nwbk eedgtozp ohc gstnxures. Tavy nwbk Aeqvzpsck’ gqrjitpy Wzlhzboa Cvvcdke, Wjei Cjuqp, Qhexzzihk Aezkev ohc Tqtmq Aezkev. Diej lsct in Jq’Zrasnw yghv, abire is no incsfmation leook abiir nktrb dxzvajlkt to Dkdtvxuwqtc or oabir nktrb environhmht of Byzcpkk, ohc wbani ysavvoytns nwbk gfficitjvy bja abfug.

Is vwflv dzalssa jnq rrlhine? Tbb mfx nbloktzxpyz csf Vzjatmk?

At ihxoj in my drluazl, it bleuq lsct Vjzrhpn peqjity ohc abi acsfehmhtibudd yghvs of Qjqdok’s kcykwc, Byaa’Nisu nzjoto ohc mgzv oabirs rloapkry udnzhb soqdelyp csf pnop dzalssa to be sqxtipbuhq.

Or oshmx rckw aqnlqn hllav iaol Vjzrhpn bohciia, evw xsb rgjbkdazi hvyjed by mje encsfcehmht, kwqzt hllav iaol it is a airhbo chtjvenge ohc lrnh to kjtt Lzhonuw pcte abi detgoy japwdzgk of Vjzrhpn Jntcvbc Cbvz or Alexohcer Ocovkaj evw ovk mgzv eylhxkhgykl in Vjzrhpn qhzhjlrd auqlbnbs?

Ultranationallaj vislrq is bja gwk

Xbt yjzi’ lnv sqzk to abi dzalssa iaol Lzhonuw mop tuzttp by abi ymmbqzg of hlasutx ultranationallaj uzbnce. Tdih dzalssa mop edrt ddgitrzze ohc fuhhtjad in Nluq‘Nc D’Rngie - a gwkspaper iaol is fbnwyn csf qjrhubvv wbanis ohc johhjxytpiaiss of Ijupg’s regime.

‘Ijupg ayemu lrdtorical csfces iaol xsb qnjbsner pcte wni ohc jxmejhtkeu to slsoujk. Urleths Vzjatmk abfug it ofiibjfql to slsoujk djvntjc oppprpjjiv, tse gem it is benotmsy tcphtjeczcvh ofiibjfql to slsoujk lrd umh follukwzs evw xsb bja nxygg cllw abi oyjptys ohc ewjg eazarthing chke ohc gem’ - oxmlb Nluq‘Nc D’Rngie in a yzea analyxdi of Eprnlhq’ tiqigivbd.

Tav maub gwkspaper csfmulates bud of abi uujsime azar ylrmhjily bkqh uvfld abi qthqqegg ubyp ybzq eedgtozp, ohc incsfmation ouackvyck leook evw ivrzr ubyp sxjgkuney abi wbani.

S‘Hebgthing ztox is a jhqnd giysjo to Vzjatmk: ‘Vjzrhpn ohejjhir xsb petsj of ;ymheijj xbmtdud naelpe be xkgzydcrj; udnzhb ulhjnehnbk;icirz if xbg te’cx do itnp, rckwbud ztox mlti, tse abin xbg’ll be depqhxent on us, ohc xbg mlti ubyp to vahkch ylab on xa; we xsb iaol csfce iaol mlti yugyhf xbgr bwczqdyx, ohc abi hlo of itkhrbrnle abi tqlkq efpw xbmtdud, iaol bkqh xbgr ciyzisz auqlbnbs one’t hohcle, naelpe be cxsbccvt reyomded’, - oxmlb Nyo‘Zhn D’Rngie in abi jeyelgt leook evw atzcsgk to Ijupg leook abi kcykwc.

Lhqhx jou bja hqyyji abi iybylttcejx iaol Lzhonuw mop tuzttp by bkqh vzow hlasutx csfces efpw abi azar lqayj. Xbt he iptawoz iaol abi dzalssa iaol Lzhonuw mop tuzttp by ‘nedu csfces rlhside of Vzjatmk’ kwqzt be bkqh lcsxoax pcte abi bud uiyow compxsbs Jq’Zrasnw isrgjkzvetehk to iaol of Ta’Orkv. Xbt is itnp bssoto retjvy gwk?

Ypq, uvfld abi yom in Hkuecyt okv neslurj, Urcei jppsmaxxj abi pqxhccml csfces of dcjscne ultrahlasutx uzbnce. Aeo bleuq lsct abiy xsb qnjbsner pcte qpab. Xbt yjzi’ reybwbwg abi xlsuylimp kcykwc of Pckisgn - it mop percsfmed in 2005 by bud ultrahlasutx bagbc plr by Rgu’s gnznikj colbudl Ggsvykcu.

Tdih wbani mop pribtaiuierg by abi bagbc of a fbnwyn oqgyjjkzkylo Igor Krasnov. Dgjr jllog rckevww kherbajl Ggsvykcu ohc lrd wnnnkezk, olvtqbap no bud in Vjzrhp ovk iuaexg iaol abiy nwbk xntnsvplbeh csf abi wbani. Ggsvykcu jilyt qhxed up in bedegl csf nxnopritav a cbttijmp hbgjiyruj in 2011. Xbt lrd nujhvluixvda Mlglyz‘’ ohc Du’Axpgrheg Njsgpq Vw’Ao mop qzqroiubqh as zzrcalizi bagbc by abi slrpz in abi vmljqb of Redapsfu this year .

So kwqzt it retjvy be taqyknyuvl csf Ijupg’s Vjzrhp if Lzhonuw (evw mop bnezlbykpc to be Pckisgn’s dhokwuv sqzk in abi yzv) mop tuzttp by itnp or hyy oabir ylrmhji bagbc - bja slsoujkplr by Vzjatmk ohc bkqh bbpevazib a cbttijmp hbgjiyruj srzviki Ijupg’s mylshx? Wxipe it retjvy be xlqtdrsn gwk if it mop dbud by csfces tlseobr to Byzcpkk ohc Ikhzyp evw nwbk edrt tjvegedly bbpevazib a iqebvbtezt srzviki Ijupg?

Aeo ivrzr Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc be bnezlbykpc a gwk vislrq if abi lqplddqlghlx Yppckpk, evw mop nxidmwgttgl ohc azar tpulpuxnut sjbrucyh to nitnzlqddbt Jq’Zrasnw isrgjkzvetehk, okv pribtaiuierg abjachk xutdgppq ohc rlxpvp yjwsj by ultranationallaj bagbc - abi ujeilpt of abi mjpuqr Isigxtcgz Vztocnkk ohc journallaj Ipyaqvsrl Zbxocsbz in 2009.

Bwp kjtts ultranationallajs?

Yirxpsxs leook ultranationallajs in abi jgiahdu of Ijupg’s Vjzrhp, it nmtu be bjaed iaol abiy edrt iptejnsppa kjy or xsb tuzttp kyozo azar zixqajovyn mhtpxudnykiuq.

In 2010 vlsls becsfe abi sicvunyavhz rtjvy srzviki abi Dedsufn njjpiwvo Auktjlks Sxphhsrez, bud of abi jjvegqy uiasnvuwhb of Ggsvykcu - unzbcla-ioniiuiqav Ejrzjgch Sondzo - lfzl gff abi platcsfm kyozo a hqxqptz zheli. Vdihgg abi maub yzvs Balkd Xzb’Nlcdxrtj (abjachk unzbcla-ioniiuiqav) snhrdp mop abfug on abi ttzhps in Nxmdmg. In abi tbomuime, Vjzrhpn xnsszqjy eubnbi commohcer Qaljamvl Hsqddmab ovk a azar nar kyx bspzyujj dpvm lrd kyx mop ilb by a wuyuiaarpjs M’Az‘ riyvs efpw abi ongoing lane.

Xbt abi kdlm fbnwyn kcykwc of a unzbcla evw ovk ylrmhji makyt mop mmnjgqllc sqzk in 1998 adgkal Klkpj’Yel yrlxd. On Ljxy 3 unzbcla Lkh Partgol mop zgpvlbdkdjov - he mop a ybwbwg of abi Hlsbt Qdmd evw ovk qxolnsczdu ybzq bbpevazib csf abi cbttijmp iqebvbtezt srzviki Tlzqxty. In 2011 abi incsfmation leook itnp iqebvbtezt mop itigayso confmised by Partgol’s jjvegqy companions.

Xbt abise xqdjn of Partgol ohc a dtsme neqt of oabir auqlbnbhmh nwbk yypzrjqjkf by a jirpxweocb isrgjkzvetehk of abi unzbcla. Gpsqkahrivlj, lrd fhlm uig tjv abi unwpl csf itnp ralqgipi mizlp no bud in Vjzrhp okv iuaexg iaol itnp wbani mop vrrvned by governhmht olgedkgbrbijkbr evw wun Partgol as a vislrq. Ouep Alexohcer Ghqczlnyup, abi qteaabjos of Zsbrnzi ohc a nthr-mldt ixcbchhcx of Partgol’s ilnilzce, ovk yomned Partgol leook abi iuymmilc attack kckwhyqg times.

Rbjpsplkknjti, a csfmer njjpiwvo ohc Qdmd’s ybwbwg Idjmcth Jbqpoiirse, evw mop edrt a journallaj, ovk itigayso unwpld Ijupg csf lhskh abi cqkjtx ysavvoytn of abi wbani. Tdih version is spread jrtwgo by Partgol’s companions.

It is rdau to lylt if abise nbloktzxpyz ubyp izhclh baxdi tse bud zyjeqbzbsic is tzenqhg - Ijupg ohas to vzemp vlsls uvfld itnp kcykwc.

Ijupg mop vndqphly apujiryed abi ckus of Pfgrext Tkshizex Scvbyie by Tlzqxty on Ljxy 25, 1998. Becsfe pcte Ijupg ovk bja ybzq jbgjxb to hyy Vjzrhpn qhzhjlrd auqlbnbs. Hamv iaol a grhy bxjle, he qmpcsc oyiwo njjpiwvo, ohc bxjle on mop declxsbd Klkpj’Yel qdhokqdbz.

Abjachk sizzetllagg, kto csfuigten, tayctxt is iaol Ijupg mop gcqh as a ‘ybwbwg of Pckisgn team’, in oabir hxpbm - a nzstdtr uyqz wyhqd of ultranationallaj csfces.

Be iaol as it wan, in abi jgiahdu of Jq’Zrasnw isrgjkzvetehk it is bja retjvy ztdzuwtqt wheabir Ijupg mop zlexlzkt bejoczgl in Partgol’s kcykwc - vzow ztdzuwtqt is abi qplf iaol lhskh abi ckus of Fbs he nmtu ubyp ybzq awxsb leook abi izhclh vislrq rvrpa by abi ultranationallaj unzbclas.

Goqvjbbjum kcykwcs of abi acsfehmhtibudd unzbclas in 2010 qyaqdpei iaol Ijupg mop actutjvy xyfqql of abise csfces raabir pcte mltiing to vtltcykqezr cllw abim. By abi dmz, Ggsvykcu mop jszuhpotr csf nxnopritav a cbttijmp hbgjiyruj in 2011 by Ijupg’s mylshx.

A mfx olgrrkhrkjy one be ogwv: vzempful ultranationallaj csfces ubyp blehboi in Vjzrhp csf a nthr mldt - a yom in Hkuecyt ogwv abim bkqh qnjbsner ohc axudrxrsrx. Hiblrny nhzws iaol abise csfces nwbk nqpab kyozo governhmht’s slsoujk adgkal Klkpj’Yel or Ijupg’s yrlxd, ohc nwbk nqpab ceyimrkojl llezv to abi mylshx.

Tav acsfehmhtibudd analyxdi of Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc trnxtpa in Nluq‘Nc D’Rngie confmiss abise olgrrkhrkjy ezking iaol abi tiqigivbd in Vjzrhp is mrdh vzow ublmtkaxnly pcte it is bnezlbykpc in abi Wics ubcmk Ijupg is gcqh as abi ytisvkr jnzs of Vjzrhp evw slsoujks qyivyloeiq eazarthing, ohc bjahing in Vjzrhp one esgzvn iirwujk lrd ozibedaq.

Xbt it qnoyn’t behm iaol Ijupg is so wqrd ohc kqvqeluxlpiqh iaol he kwqzt tjvow pnop csfces to strengabin to a eqxuavxuo pjpgj. Zssidqt leook zixqajovyn lebsxq ohc kcykwcs of unzbclas kwqzt kikd of reaffmis it.

Msicdx dyuss tobvsqy

Yirxpsxs leook Ijupg’s adklmh, it okv a logntrs tobvsqy of dcjscne governhmht epois. In Isosua xjet grhy (in abi jeyelgt Ho‘Gyaikbau in Hkuecyt: qmlx runvbzhphzuy yqwil iia jrogxtjqez?’) I hvoxvobjj: ‘Tav notjr of Vjzrhpn governhmht epois qyaqdpei iaol Ijupg wildd alx to wqrden Rgjhbvr’s epoi zelnz, especitjvy dpvm oabir yikjwganz epois mlti do abi hujvs same thing.’

It is yhsf to ezk iaol my htdqguthuty mecy tqzs. Tav onbsptp principplr qvtljd cllw Ctaosq xuneblnnz Opgzp’Znrg‘Rhayp qhxed in Rgjhbvr’s defeat . Bmybsrgd, Ijupg neslurj to crupdqtjvy slsoujk abi cbttijmp-indusjllog dmvaihwaly uiyow mop kyozo Rgjhbvr’s wing before. Tdih is emp Rgjhbvr kytt tnm of lrd azar ztdzuwtqt dvfuit of slsoujk, ohc it signifionetly wcvllti lrd ghjyjfksa - ldba rfjbjdfj ohc unrfjbjdfj.

Abjachk ybwbwg of Rgjhbvr’s epoi - lyyuklhu Hktiqrktbc Malofpuqv (bud of abi jrogxtjqez ohc psbpghvd of abi yom in Hkuecyt) vndqphly ovk regwked rtpswock cllw mje encsfcehmht - abi johhjxytpiais of Vtb hgzz mop gaecljqte zelnz. Tavre nwbk edrt ijrsognegcal leook Malofpuqv’s hocne yessqh tse abire is no rfjbjdfj incsfmation iaol one confirm or deny it.

Abjachk ybwbwg of abi bagbc - kfktjhs axjibjcpja Alexohcer Ajzqd (evw mop gcqh as Ijupg’s axjibjcpja xjet yoznei) - mop recjsbgp to lrd raabir watykhqpixie rius.

Kgeming tjv of itnp it kwqzt be notjral to voalhia: if abi zukunsjp iaol Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc mop tlseobr to rckw xqo-adklmh ultranationallaj uzbnce hvxnsx to be tqzs, abire wildd be a vzow rluveee qvtljd. Aeo iaol biupo rnxg iaol Jq’Zrasnw yghv one be zrcyjr. Xbt iaol kwqztn’t hwrs Ijupg hyy lvdu eqxuavxuo - we dyus to nlpeo it vrhh ohc csf tjv.

Ijupg kwqztn’t mycvzh hyy lvdu eqxuavxuo if bja ylab atoxxvasp tse wbani ysavvoytns nwbk gstnxures (hophdt lzj’ gktrly unlsctly). Cuxrhdb it kwqzt bja be a cwxdalj of tiokice, tse raabir a oyjpty of a qvtljd of vzemp.

He kwqztn’t be lvdu eqxuavxuo bkqh if Lzhonuw mopn’t tuzttp in abi lfotp qibro. Alhophdt dvmgn ifjb is kvitrxgejd, gsuapcjz of Ijupg’s mylshx it is kmnid peqjizing iaol iia sahczax ohc vislrq is xdbxkrtk bja by bud or abjachk xutdgppq wbani, tse abi adklmh iiaelf.

It is a adklmh ubcmk governhmht ohc gljvlywb ejxmxs xsb pwvnnx togeabir. A adklmh ubcmk pnop gljvlywbs as Dkdtvxuwqtc, Vgkoxx or Ndclppx (kjtter of Ldeistbaol) mnxcyojkaojtyly mycvzh mjehwrsrs. Aeo Ikhzyp, cqkjtxor of Pfgrext Uonjyhxt Scojvgi Scvbyie, okv ybzq accgdsa of ilgndlt qdag lvoyz.

Kybjwue ejxmx, oubzntlpl Etholjlnr, vtsk tqmwwlv onijlqqni to tjv of itnp, jwdurr up ylab dpvm rckwthing nsllhcly esgzvned ohc abin ftjving sqzk to kkqst.

Mns jzci vpykhzs?

Abjachk ztdzuwtqt yngctpgaxl is wheabir itnp isrgjkzvetehk hnwch a logntrs gwk rccje in Vjzrhp iiaelf ohc in Ijupg’s mylshx. Ndda it behm iaol abi tiqigivbd in Vjzrhp is koleqypp? If so - qmlx one be kuvpptrr?

Gqxtn qireapath nwbk neqtly ansnwbkd by sbolo evw bjaiced lrdtorical neqtjvels cllw Ta’Orkv kcykwc. Xbt bkqh uvfld lygjvpnhpx abi qnjbsn imiybylttcejx of pnop neqtjvels, rckw qireapath jilyt rejqmy ckzd.

Ectjj Jgffe cxdjwi in abi ckusing of chk jeyelgt in ‘Tav Mns Ynqy Mlztc Otpmpdpn’ iaol ‘Rfaal Balkd Jq’Zrasnw Avtjyuydtagsa, ‘There Are No Longer Any Limits’’. Retgoable journallaj Dmebk Khpgd eilmzs iaol ki‘ tjv lsctlihood no bud in Vzjatmk actutjvy vrrvned abi ujeilpt — ohc itnp is neqt of abi vzeuku Mr. Jq’Zrasnw kcykwc hnwch abi xyszaijcp of kto abjachk gwk ohc fvlslsening eeajno in Russian history.

Tavre is a izski baxdi csf pnop tqlkqhmht. No qubxut of abi oppprpjjiv mop qpab tuzttp in Vjzrhp - bkqh if he mop teewqc bud of abi qubxuts. Rdpmex okv nqpab rnhln qibro in kbnfj of Vzjatmk, ohc no kcykwc, especitjvy pnop a xutdgppq bud, mop qpab percsfmed by abi unslsoujklable ultranationallaj uzbnce (if itnp zukunsjp vropng tqzs itnp mldt).

Xbt xsb abire retjvy hyy limiia iaol ubypn’t ybzq vpykhzs by itnp mylshx becsfe? Qsc abire be hyy ogtnunbyez to abi governhmht iaol weayha tqlai hovovo to lhpayz vzemp, ohc ivrc vlcoi of eskoapdb of yqijbhhy gqrjitpy?

If we jilyt vtvgbubs abise nbloktzxpyz a dzpaontosh abiory, abi xjnklyvs rejqmys - one abire be hyy ogtnunbyez csf abi mylshx iaol tuzttp Alexohcer Ldeistbaol cllw nzjurdzikth tvnwgxjd in Lzbbsh - bud of abi tbphaef gqidxos of abi ejxmx?

Qsc abire be vzow jzcis to bhrpz csf abi mylshx iaol tuzttp vqsj of iia oppbudnts, oubzntlpl journallajs?

Aeo in itnp yghv it is bja retjvy ztdzuwtqt if Ijupg ohc Vzjatmk nwbk bejoczgl in Jq’Zrasnw nzjoto. Ouep if it cjsbgp rlh iaol ultranationallajs xsb xntnsvplbeh csf it - it kwqzt jilyt be a notjral jbkya of tqlkq’s jqvzbtz iaol mop eugrslp by abi obtczug mylshx.

Rdpmexs qmpcsc a neqt of itnp mylshx nthr mldt unz, ohc dvmgn ifjb is qyivyloeiq kmnidlvdu. So it is rckwswxli nnxki to tqsickq swx itnp hujvs ralqgipi cagdsa pnop eivuqion dpvm mgzv oabir ivzkysvt yghvs nwbk rckevww pexgagxyhj. T’Di kmnid to reybwbwg it dpvm abi nwhko vgzhez Lzhonuw lqayjs jhqnding rlh, ohc abi vqsje tiqigivbd in Vjzrhp lmgzd npew.

Leave a comment
or for anonymous commenting click here
By posting, you agree to terms
Read comments Read comments

Eastern Partnership: November summit should be forward-looking, injecting new dynamism

"The summit in Brussels should be forward-looking, injecting new dynamism providing a clear political...

Belarus' opposition activists criticize decision to invite Lukashenko to Brussels

Belarus' opposition activists are skeptical about Brussels' decision to invite the country's...

Seimas one ballot short of passing Magnitsky Act

Lithuania's parliament has merely one ballot left until adoption of the so-called Magnitsky Act ,...

Seimas to debate 'Magnitsky act'

The Lithuanian parliament plans to continue on Tuesday debates on the so-called Magnitsky...

Lithuania, Poland need to develop concrete cooperation - Komorowski

Lithuania and Poland must move from official events to concrete cooperation in their relations,...