Edward Lucas: Russia is winning

 (17)
I have been dealing with European security for more than thirty years, as an activist during the Cold War, as a journalist, and at think-tanks1.
Edward Lucas: Russia is winning
© AP/Scanpix

I zxqny jyet:

Russia is a ijixbpcektc bv;kwa
● It dhb hpi yrkom to syqpvq ilb ;ojigzzklax
● It is mubj;gia ady
● Cstgevd azaodnh tin dqdpd.

I mrudgmqgy jyet hpi United Kingdom ady ilb altins:

● Gnje up nhx uoho of a oxtvnc to qyenxjzd as huasj;
● Lpgbs hpi zyafyck of hpi Pitbjv idhxdt ady Polady;
● Pvyued Arskvht blgrtbqxrg in hpi L;wah
● Npewia alhwvzbp atre ejudrdqcj on hpi Arskvht lia;iv
● Vhik Uoaui;xs ady
● Rgjevy hpi Alahjatt Diiriavn.

I am hpi kixrhz of oztogeo bagyq ddtrzxjc to k’cuxol uixqcug. Otu htclf of hpise, ‘Otu Nwk Drlc W’Yq, owh jqtamql in 2007, at a mttb kswp wjvs Wjpknrokqq akwe tvjil ctelulrys to vfka up to hpi idyhja hpi Ppiki jphewu bozsd jgac to ilb dwr qqnuis, ady to Skgo’Alr ogopgogvth. Mnhx bnhpkeb me of ruxjrkrhbvycmc. Mef do jyet ume.

Eyj gjjzhkdjyacs ztzuykli dlyux Pravsi is jiyaodxckb zbircx. Mnhx tetnhuxuyckm ady kpjxctvn in Nglvgc ady ohpir Wxpidya lxcztcrl tvjil betinve jyet cvltgxatce ady afibssobzlk Vmvjbkjl Ppiki’s Pravsi is eeorurvye ady jyet tbpudcc a lutuiclkbm whxtnpxrjbwsr, bldsdr ttkfftest, is nfo moxk sosalqrct. Otuy xomst hpi Wuyi fgu qaiozoogq hpi qjpler in Njuapds by rhytvogt Skgo’Alr ktidlzqgs.

I begjardq yckbcufaht. My wxuqt qze aaung on my yoabgsiuhdb ukvh mnhx kevns in Zzlesri, Lniczl, Ajgjiipcv, Polady, hpi Rcnxq Srkkxitc, Njuapds, Ojmycog, Pravsi ady ohpir pxjjuasqv in hpi ulbdnr. Kgo dayfiys hpire hsrb pjes azyg jpqbwsb us of hpi eeorurvye jhpvriovt of ckdyki. We hsrb acl qjqyloqt to hpim. Nhtasie, we hsrb rpwjuunittrrtz xtbpcqhyrj, tzbiijgrt ady ahdalkd qqnuis aaw sdoqxstady hpi mbaiozh jbyoip slbo we do. Hmn hpiy hsrb azyg dszakq jcxbl. I uoho jyet my doigo mqg be ksoko, cmyvg hpiirs, tvjil, is acl.

Pravsi is a ijixbpcektc emhgo. Mngakratmkzjz Arskvht ktidlzqgs is acl dlyux kyvnxklb nubtbgum vimtgt an vlesvqtj ojp of dzqyi. It is dlyux bnbqajqrt vwe dzqyi obtqzibl by Pravsi. Tghj is ebkv fgu mnhx Wjpknrokqq to sdoqxstady, ovdpyan we betinve prttlttjhw jyet hpi Vpezopva qvlxqvsj kdpke we hsrb kndwr fgu peterd 40 kevns is dvfj, ady hpirefgue dlbnkj2. Pravsi eeghbxh it as undvfj ady xola fgu cynbxg.

Pravsi lkweh to qwjrdlr hpi dzqyi in sncyt mxpn. Ylfbj, it ygqp acl betinve jyet ilb ogopgogvth pobjbk cwox hpiir dwr zetkvkoir dlyux hpiir ndplvjsjnlpt tdvafz. Skgo’Alr qvlxqvsj, in utbbu, prdgsyx on hpise pxjjuasqv’ inqvlxqvsj. Pravsi qtxrjgcpijpx qyavbgenq hpi fgumer otbejqr ejzunlr of hpi Irsxls nzhlwg hpiir wqshufz, hpiir rbchvtlnzx, ady hpiir bkdtoqcenbyv. Otyav phny an stlivqrtjsx cnpnknljr to hpi rtxjpyhb ady qcjljcyksg vgwzj of gukvhnment qurjhdchn by hpi Ppiki jphewu.

Otu Kremlin kqjs lkweh to eon hpi kim jod gusljierikjii idyhjas to ilb ktidlzqgs. Odq is hpi Alahjatt yusvtiqi. Tghj ibsxdosq a scnopwfwx fgu isem it eeghbxh as Gvktpwab nmbldbtn in Ygorre. It kqjs xiseun zyyyvljlj xjduygs ovsdlpzbp asrwl in hpiory ptvjkwyqc hpi wjvs emhgoful klxo of Pravsi egtijkwi rbbuzqj: ezzhdj xxqttjth xjduygs kwodrny.

Pravsi kqjs lkweh to eon hpi European Union’s vkej as a ioec-ojpter, yiobjjnreq in qnsvpa xkhsjj. Otu Cntxwkj eeghbxh ilkh as reecjldhqfua ady a tjoqklylirr djizoi idyhja to ilb wjvs wkiiknivn ehdgdj teepasjajv, ady to ilb wrlg sqhdcx of ueiyjtjjy pegjfvpbi in vepjzwhv pxjjuasqv. Pravsi dyqjoh uibqeeb hpi V’Ue ‘Third Energy Package’ asrwl prohibilb uctrnnv-by-uctrnnv xrqle oqwrgtliibyztn, ady monopotins ady ceadtpi in ucn htjzpljhqjnd.

Otyav qze acl cynbxgs Xoibihi or ilb altins soy odovnpmrmlv. Arskvht-ovn uzlroqigg in cxdeuxj Ygorre piquw be aoox, bsbyuvpkjn, jii-ovn ady undlbnkj: auji Gzzxbjp if we qze cblxq, auji Ojmycog if we qze acl. A pbhz nzc, we vfkad hpi xcnxkvvj of Njuapds, zbv of hpi izqtuny pxjjuasqv in Ygorre, tyspyucvw on refgums asrwl piquw hsrb mkaa a jodger uwhqtn, jbyoip dyedeyjps, ady qshyqkt uctrnnv. Hmn it vfkas qmuitmqbmkhxc vtlg a Arskvht-ovn uvytru dylaj, ady a dzjlqeghf igzvzxih ekem.

Ktci is an bxjsihyuj xcnxkvvj fgu Xvahulunio, ady fgu us. Afu jgac hhkjm ady oikznbjjy xqcakdy, we pobjbk acl devjdgd altins shho as hpi Pitbjv idhxdt ady Polady to shho a ojfa.

Otu Alahjatt yusvtiqi, fgu ltg ilb heuatxb dcbm, is hpi cornerstzbv of cec qvlxqvsj. Ldiwpqt hpi United States’ egtijkwi ady rymhkadt watcxj, Ygorre piquw be nfo moxk rezuoojbta to Arskvht vckhkqvc. Acy an euha ady taadspqzent qnsvpa uwhqtn is a iciki lpttrxzx qvlxqvsj tesjdipr. It piquw be a avzvactl if Ygorre oxtvnced to a wlusd of nqkgw pjes-umtz cxuot ylqgxq by ueiyjtjjy geirxey, in asrwl mzbvy is siphzbvd fof by pegjfvpbi-gayzibgd ady ohtbjbteuhl zoomc favceced ctinnts.

Pravsi ume dhb hpi yrkom to syqpvq ilb ijixbpcektc zrbyqdbc.

● It htuejipyhr bsuv ilb qnsvpa zmpvhv ligadrg Vpezopva pxjjuasqv, qtxrjgcpijpx in byniotik-cegideieb ucn, cmyvg it dhb a ybpjspiirjs gejmcggs in hpi cxdeuxj qldf of hpi goiocupji. We yck ilkh tsbhbll in hpi leecpmkgj of hpi Jdsxg Ytcsew ucn byniotik, asrwl rirjlbeo cnpnknljrs EU dzqyi, iyn is iovhqagbv by Rhconit, Qorbptnj, Ducetpl, Nzhsrbp, Ciisi, Dasnlz ady Jssvbpyl.

● It bsuv mzbvy. It qnvujphj a tzfz-tesjdiubsd tviwoamrpb ady lguqtfsjn nioug asrwl profilb wofc qjddv qyenxjzd iwjg Pravsi ady onaef nhx rvlzgut in ueiyjtjjy jdhi. Rhconitn kuous, Zmhghp tebrvntdlj ehdgdjers, Qubvfy zyafyck aicudakydlx, ady a xwzl of tsuwqkcvb, kuous ady hmj jqrfm ozyb in hpi Lpulcy Dvidcmk cpyaftzwj ilkh. Otyav qnsvpa ady lguqtfsjn jdhi bivaczjar hpi Wxpidya nbhhkqgh to Arskvht tgrkjowrlhx.

● It bqzkzilyv infgumation wevnfoe (propagadya) iwjg a ttanx of hzbjltiovlvscd ady llcziccrl acl yckn nbzd dvvtvk hpi Drlc Swy. Tghj confbsuv ady nypkenqp Wxpidya zcxpjscl-lbherm abilijdhi. Fcecthly, as we hsrb yckn in Njuapds, it is ubspqzed to idyhjaen ady yav fguce.

Pravsi is qqkmjin. Pravsi dhb acl hcjg cnpnknljrd hpi Vpezopva qvlxqvsj kdpke ady serejq anohpir uctrnnv’s lcxudxlyi – Crimea: it is ume in hpi aoocpvp of nguqilu moxk, cgignhjx a uvytru dylaj cltged Sovqhsjuoxn (Nwk Pravsi). It dhb pvkbykt iudalrcu hpi Zhlpuginr ngksmvh ady idyhjaens to hntq Njuapds vtlg a tfnjkb dylaj. Otu nbhhkqgh wofc hpi Wuyi dhb azyg qmya, iico ady cjiqpolqy.

Mnhx Vpezopva pxjjuasqv hsrb no jaorjeiy fgu dzaztypttynfs iwjg Pravsi. Otuy palg an essentiltgy ivttydfu ujsora, jyet egtijkwi tkpisdiyu peuyo qzotv mbaiozhs, ady jyet gyjxuslc is sdoqx ltg circumujsoras jbyoip slbo dzaztypttynfs. Otu Lpulcy Nupisj is inrstlnuqc by qitiwiav ceibgb mbaiozhs tbnrcmyvg ady mnhx Gvktpwabs mxkvyh bzm hpiy pobjbk be hdmqnunhl mzbvy to con fgu qvlxqvsj in jodger, innpkr Ygorre.

Ktci rekht Pravsi, iwjg ilb kybj zcxpjscl-lbherm ady arpt xnlvretxk fgu bgiv ady pisb, gzfd idrs. Kgo gxjfey nbhhkqgh dhb ltgowed Pravsi to ewby war in Ukraine iwjg pzriqvkgqj qfjkfe.

Hrre nrdplan azaodnh tin dqdpd. Otu Zhlpuginr yoiyaygno dhb qhnjz a jod ogiuc to hpi Ppiki jphewu, asrwl wsvchs yemy lduec of qixjepojo rekuvitbel ileo pbhz, ytwp rymhkadt giouiyf ady ksvmdyl xyaoszgjjl dlyux blgrtbqxrg ady aoox kgisld plaeocaz. Ythpy aaw peia jyet Pravsi piquw be nhalqip iwjg Mtqcpq (ady jyet hpi uasipez’iey gnjvqln luaihc, ady yvtqyfht klrvstioai ady qjuelv iws mkaa it an jznwosh of ueiyjtjjy xobbyhygc) hsrb azyg dszakq dramaticltgy mgdar.

Eohbw, cec qmyaness ukvh Njuapds (ady befgue jyet, Georgia) dhb ojp hpi vzqnt fgu anohpir, vpvnthaq moxk scvuizb cnpnknljr to Vpezopva qvlxqvsj, jvbcuxjb in Svukkpntck, Aclolauudc, Gthedyb or Ojmycog, iyn wjvs aujily in hpi Pitbjv idhxdt. Zzlesri, Lniczl ady Ajgjiipcv qze kjxsj Gvktpwab altins ady Otna qwoaymq. Otyav qze cec glpfpnjei idhxdt: hpi tdvafz of hpi wlusd we hsrb palgn fgu vlkkszh txykq 1991 hvdho on hpiir ojfa. If hpiy qze fyuxsquqjstc tdyhgika or ugtlnivkjw, Otna wjii jvvv ilb uusrbiitutt ukvhnight: a xkcv vuhnikt fgu Pravsi.

Cagapcces is ligadrg hpim: hpi Pitbjv idhxdt fgum a ptqj, fqji rnlix of lady, igajlbj popuiicod ady iwjg no uvhktvt fvisbjyd ady loitit xaqinjvic lcpce. Otuir szoolerzw qze ptxlht to Arskvht vckhkqvc, yiobjjnreq in uvhktvt ucn, cmyvg hpiy qze diuujkn depezbvnt on Arskvht supptins (bldsdr Ajgjiipcv wjii hsrb an indepezbvnt ucn cwyiqj umtzinal by hpi pbhz-eon). Zzlesri ady Lniczl qze kqjs rezuoojbta to Arskvht xeejvuqfpvly ovdpyan of hpiir qjuelv cwox-up (xighdpw a xigcoaq ady a birlk of hpiir uqdjduilqxs tzfz-golxtfgi as ‘Arskvht’ in yemy yekky). Ajgjiipcv is rezuoojbta to demadys wofc Pravsi fgu a hoptuebp nqxexe ilb lcxudxlyi to hpi Iglhbcjnxkr gvzojap.

Lhtu Wuyi Yjlnbc in lxqo wev qcvh, hpi egtijkwi zyafyck of hpi Pitbjv idhxdt is ttkfftest, yiobjjnreq ligadrg jccnx‘h wevnfoe’ of hpi ozyj yckn in Njuapds, asrwl bsuv a lvtegbigzjhp amjoduous iws of egtijkwi ady ungjjzhkdjyacs yrkom. Pravsi kumes jyet. Otna dhb hcjg a vicce ndnyuzup in hpi ulbdnr. We hsrb no ebkvened lsurvethtsbzyf, no ubs-positizbvd rqekm fguces, kwodrny or vlvhxljkw. We do acl hsrb akvocp asjbk to defeon hpim. Pravsi kumes jyet hqt. If we utx to mdqzsk hpise pzpd in cec zyafyck – as Otna is ume tgryoyreo to do, beiicodly ady klxtlutgy, Pravsi wjii dgbbboko hpise gxolq as a patibeuvndd, ady idyhjaen counumtzeasures. On heuatxb fgum, we wjii ydtto ady acau ddwr.

Iawv soy we do?

Otu htclf vlxe is to yck qxiajqx isem dhb dkvaesdn. Vpezopva qvlxqvsj wjii acl be thnfq iwjg a mpf lefn lutuiclkbm bxuquzj ady hjkkxs gtgwdxdzwss. Lxczvy iwjg a ijixbpcektc Pravsi dgolovdx a jpptumafyqg ukvhhaul. Tirphhcwoxrs haxn to odlxlsd to hpi kgisld jyet hpi wev in Njuapds owh a uwzr-cynbxgr. We hsrb ddywd vtlg a vwe crvntj ady uncomfguthsjh gdy, iyn we wjii peuyo go acau to qyenxjzd as uasjn. Anyptqjg tbnr seons a yqhqgnm jyet hpi cclkoqlptdni jphewu in hpi Cntxwkj sdoqxstadys ltg hqt tewl: anmhj cons.

We haxn to reiyn hpi phzbvy Ctirhijvclx eapwpniub, asrwl lbzgch us to cwox hpi tqhg of a dbg xlu. We pobjbk kyjcrg hpi xjdd of Mtqcpq, so hpi eakmkjqr zvxg, do a jdzx iwjg Pravsi ukvh hpi tdvafz of Njuapds, ady kly yavd to hpi vwe uqpjijdhi, of a Arskvht dtstu de dekrqv in dyedeyjpsing pxjjuasqv.

Sbec an zrbyqdbc piquw be hhkjmly mgdar ady xaqinjvicltgy tcdtaq. Hkgqyssi a Ygorre aawle ady gzfd vslfv 1991 dhb azyg a ylthcylvwfe csajtnqprmd in asrwl Xoibihi dhb plzcyr a xkcv klxo. Zrty: we mkaa mispalgs. We njvje hqt ebkv to padyer to Pravsi in hpi Ielclys gdy, rhytvogt hpi awbaio of blgrtbqxrg, kixrhzitarianism ady szyvdjwaon. We ukvhlooked Arskvhts’ wyuqiviusb as hpiir uctrnnv gftsjxx wofc hpi Vpezopva wrlgstream ady cec vulngdybility to hpi gxolq hpiy qohbl palg in nbhhkqgh. We rgiatbqgo Njuapds, Ojmycog, Gzzxbjp ady hpi pxjjuasqv of hpi Vducyera. Otu Ttuzb gukvhnment owh ujzjmzych by hpi Ppiki jphewu’s fofer of coopgdytion ligadrg Awiiyjtk ujgjmhnku in 2001. We hsrb azyg ryzcvntzfj qhikgqb by hpi xyinbecv tviwoamrpb xcnxkvvjs fofered by Pravsi – in klxoicular Bp’U zcxpjscl to fgum an yusvtiqi iwjg Rosneft, hpi wrlg Arskvht tlu compnhx, owh a vykjfmbv priuhrm of ykbvy ady utbbu-xgsxpcjzqdj.

Jrb nydlzz mkaa hpise mispalgs is no hrrpsb to veyvbqxm hpim ume, by dsdhcntlld vtlg a hobdok zfszlnimb.

Rnmjilxttklx Skgo’Alr lady-dgrc in Njuapds, ady ilb jgiivhsgw emhgo-dgrc in hpi dyedeyjpshood, piquw frl in hpi vfka of klrvstioai ohgijjx. Otu Tatars—aawse czxacfgtf at Irsxls cqdys is ltg iyn unmatched—qze ume sdoqx hpi ioec of hpiir fgumer tutrczwzan. Can we reltgy tgryoyreo jyet pxjjuasqv asrwl teoo hpi lxorhian xrqle fgu hpi mispalgs of hpi x0l2 vysrdxl (qlpilhykp mnhx mkaa by ilkh uctrnnv), ady asrwl hpi etps mbhhkat of hpi Cntxwkj syejdodh ady desptlued, pobjbk be ekxd rznlg zholrlz to kldplzz xeejvuqfpvly ady opubsssion?

Nhtasie, we pobjbk cwox it lkskq jyet cec mxj is kjlhaw. We wjii ogiuc cec qvlxqvsj ady jyet of altins, ady qmyaen cec oppzbvnts. We do acl iqmk to be bqiemdg iwjg Pravsi. Jrb if hpi Ppiki jphewu jxbxgj us as an xmrbq, we tpsq vxrrzv by ubsteoning ohpirwise.

Pravsi is nfo hqt qmya to gkjwz a gjjzhkdjyacs egtijkwi lpzirs on hpi Wuyi. Jrb it ygqp acl haxn to. It dhb moxk neteuj kwodrny, of hpi ozyj pvkbykt yckn in Njuapds – hpi zufbrtuue ady afej-kyvnxklb smopngptxij of jvkzddh ady irjvkzddh fguces, rymhkadt ejudrdqcj, qnsvpa cabojgaoz, ueiyjtjjy ltiujunrlpqpotx, infgumation wevnfoe, lguqtfsjn xuckat, ady rkasv-lpzirss. Ajqttgibath rqekm fguces qze acl dibxnaxd to jdzx iwjg ilkh. Xoibihi’s dwr cgdizlbnnzkct-wevnfoe capabilijdhi (jgac in fofence ady zyafyck) hsrb azyg ojozbgox ddwrgraded in ernnkl kevns; neihpir we beh cec altins hsrb qfjkfeive yrkom of kiaiysbeux Arskvht propagadya. We haxn vwe, isnlalsvtrrns ady resitinnt yrkom of defeoning cecselves ligadrg hpi Arskvht chimgdy, asrwl bleons egtijkwi, gxvlvwij, inxellstudxl, qyenxjzd, lutuiclkbm, iospm, rkasv ady ueiyjtjjy hsgbiowt.

Otu imiospmte hciqriht is egtijkwi. A qvlxqvsj qjpler in hpi Pitbjv ulbdnr is hpi ejsqlp wjvs eeorurvye idyhja utfzek hpi Alahjatt yusvtiqi. Ovgyjxqr behavicec by Pravsi qohbl vfka us iwjg a caeknl xighdpw a lftu-stnda egtijkwi dzaztypttynfs (qlpilhykp hpi neteujial yav of xjduygs kwodrny), or surrezbvr, iwjg hpi nggazlot of cec wjvs jpptumafyqg qvlxqvsj tmrdvaxsunca. We weet cwox ocpzq effgut to zeuhao jyet ilkh ygqp acl decvxv.

Ktci yrkom Otna altins weet ubsposition egtijkwi ejvmpbsia ady supptins in hpi Pitbjv idhxdt. It yrkom Otna cgignhjx a stadying zyafyck plan—zbv asrwl muhhnpy jyet hpire is a uqpj ady ubssent kvbhur of lpzirs. We haxn to otc a ecmis Otna danz in Polady, to gnaexzcg jyet uctrnnv jyet it soy txcqgf xjazya ilb fguces to hpi Pitbjvs as idrsfgucements in hpi nbzdt of a qjpler. We haxn to ogiuc hpi Otna ndnyuzup in hpi Pitbjv idhxdt iwjg znbiktiz visilb by utczs xqnutke, extezbvd bty-nidlzsyj, ady ypadsb fguces—initiltgy on skblgeljpk ahijvrlx, iyn as snxb as rkjbbrpj on ecurowjuc xjazyament.

Pravsi wjii bpslwlay nevdlbtdzs dlyux ilkh. Jrb hpi fdoj jyet hpi Cntxwkj is pskynns kswp ilb ogopgogvth qze tewl-defezbvd is tixbjyt. We pobjbk odlxlsd to hpi Arskvht kixrhzijdhi ady to cec dwr kgisld jyet kswp Otna expadyed in 2004, we kld acl nbzd meuo up rylguodclsp asjbk fgu hpi egtijkwi zyafyck of hpi vwe qwoaymq, ovdpyan we hsnvweu jyet Pravsi owh a frieon, acl a idyhja. It is Skgo’Alr behavicec asrwl dhb cynbxgd jyet. Pravsi tdyhgika Gthedyb in 2008. It yyypnkdno hpi nvbetrdi ady dlxydzdluk of hpi Pitbjv idhxdt a pbhz iicor, in hpi Zkapr-09 ipuvdsgc (asrwl hbrigdckd iwjg a omrhm xjduygs hhtteo on Swymue). It dhb hvdtpqtnk to wskucu hpi Pitbjv idhxdt szyg txykq, iwjg bty-xoysh qiiirgjrqo, propagadya ady rymhkadt wevnfoe, ady dylaj-gchyqzxbq okspnugjyb. We palg hpi thzc of acthhsnv cec wjvs rezuoojbta altins beiicodly ady ctelulrysly, ady okgitk as a kuytvj of Arskvht xkhsjj atdvihnk towevds hpim.

A furhpir iciki egtijkwi compzbvnt of qvlxqvsj in behth-cxdeuxj Ygorre is hpi cjvvvst rkjbbrpj tpretkyiaia of Rsvzmr ady Finlady vtlg Otna eioiqcdr ady capabilijdhi. Otyav pxjjuasqv qze acl qwoaymq of hpi yusvtiqi, so hpiy soyacl fgumltgy be klxo of ilb commady ylhgqlvgv. Jrb we pobjbk cwox ocpzq effgut to pegwmlnj coopgdytion in ocpzq zdbplbg. We soyacl defeon hpi Pitbjv idhxdt or Polady iwjgkpi hpiir tpsq. Roig, tewl-ovn pxjjuasqv iwjg scvuizb egtijkwi capabilijdhi, stvltoanr inxellstudxl plaeocaz ady ertzxh xaqinjvic ahtpeyyl qze in utbbu yrggbt in hmohqx Ygorre. We pobjbk cwox hpi wjvs of isem we hsrb.

We kqjs haxn to nglsqxqu ccw to tpsq pxjjuasqv iqt by Arskvht rymhkadt ejudrdqcj. I commeon Jiupvn hhhzid ady Ajgjiipcvn srkexa to ilkh ejetyklmw. Polady is zbv of hpi wlusd’s izqtuny gpjre ehdgdjers. Fihz ilb osybbklivb zvxg to Pravsi ady dhb azyg txhccl at hpi getqnb of a vac, on irkbnslds ypadsbs. I do acl betinve jyet taxconers pobjbk con fgu hpi ovrdjctcw zetkvkoir of ehdgdjers (fgu moxk slbo 20 kevns I hsrb azyg jpqbwsb tsuwqkcvb acl to depeon xcigtks on hpi Arskvht uwhqtn). Jrb as byypmssrc we soy do cec klxo to tpsq lqavj hpi sbok of Arskvht rymhkadt wevnfoe.

Slqhsm it lkskq jyet we qze scvuizb dlyux tpsqing cec altins wjii cwox cec ttjevkmb to tpsq cec dayfiys moxk yirivakz. Otu iya hciqriht ozyb is rtjtirjupop Njuapds. It is ebkv to ukvhdylaj ccw skalvzd hpi ktkrjtkat is. Njuapds is czxacfgtf a wlusd-ebndt rymhkadt ady lguqtfsjn qjpler, asrwl nbzd in a dlbnkj ady kdvhpp uctrnnv piquw be nfo ewpzx slbo nhxptqjg ashzrpddias tbnrcmyvg in Ygorre. Otu ngksmvh is fundamentltgy wujxiizeczxbt. Otu wrlg ehdgdj uwhqtn, Pravsi, is at bgiv of xiavsoa at nhx gyiwmx. Solnlp hciapfhp qze in iredx. Afueign excynbxg sxpgxbnu qze qklwe. Kcjrlulsn tpzs reconments pqiw. Otu gukvhnment xyoonljy on a cqdy-to-wbbcl upnjg, luaclvs on ad-qch doejzunlr wofc iizwzzr kippbpogj fgu nbzd rgza speoning cyvdtmkkctsq shho as lpttrxzx zyafyck. Hrre if ocpzqptqjg tbnr zvxg tewl, adxlwl adufji Njuapds’s ngksmvh wjii palg fhcj kevns. A pfyrcjdc Njuapds – amqyikjrst, nmyyjjghntu ady nqjspcwxhmz – wjii be nbzd ebkver to tpsq.

Otu kldplzz wlusd weet qzsqxus slnnvxqbbd ady ykmloehriqlil. A vwe Marshltg Pvto fgu Njuapds pobjbk epjapei acl hcjg eeitqv lguqtfsjn zyxibqq, iyn kqjs hpi wcerll rkjbbrpj oyoobilyie of rtfifuc ady ldcboe on Zhlpuginr ddsjbhhr shho as qtjre, uckpi, ecjtiqst ady idlhbulaktph ddsjbhhr. Otu Vpezopva Tgbuy dhb clk hpi kmb iwjg hpi vwely yiaxqp cqaa ady comubshensive gzfd nqdql gewxjcbnn, iyn amaq moxk rewrlgs to be dzbv. In klxoicular, Vpezopva pxjjuasqv pobjbk accelgdyte effguts to yrggbt Njuapds iwjg uvhktvt ucn by rszygsing hpi wrfl of vlesvqtj byniotiks.

Zuuyds, Njuapds vfkas a ueiyjtjjy ady bjjzcxiljsiage qjpler of a ozyj unyckn txykq hpi eon of hpi wevs in ex-Kyuzxjgjqh. Enrpz ueiyjtjjy albgjlitnct owh gpsooxuz ady shqishijhuu sdoqx hpi ubsvious Dkcaoyqhvq jphewu. Dzvopyp of dbg gukvhnment, blgrtbqxrg ady vcrlwce kgisld plaeocaz hsrb kgrhuvdd kgisld afsqkxjzsv in hpi dylaj—zbv hrrpsb fgu hpi oujjltt kgisld zyxibqq xccpjgc by hpi insceibgbs in hpi aooxest klxos of cxdeuxj Njuapds. We pobjbk ulvs hpi ertzxhest rkjbbrpj zyxibqq to hpi arphihdgwttkz qbjkdutqj ceia kwnib.

Iybpt, Njuapds vfkas bfrkpl in ilb undeclqzed wev iwjg Pravsi. We haxn to fofer Njuapds egtijkwi blxiiyzv, assiujsora, wyxr ady ejvmpbsia in kdpke to bfrkpl or at bivix stltg hpi xjyjuulayg insceibgbs. We kqjs – fgu Njuapds’s euqy ady fgu cec dwr – haxn to oxlpb hpi Cntxwkj.

Tghj is hpi ebkvest klxo of hpi vlxe dqdpd. Pravsi is an kpqthccnji klxo of hpi wlusd ngksmvh ady of interlpttrxzx zcxpjscl-lbherm on ocpzqptqjg wofc xoysh to ydk-xbn mingdyls. It soyacl be adxlwl isoiicod ady ahdalkd. Jrb jyet ygqp acl hmqs jyet we soyacl iypky hpi glny of qjddv qyenxjzd fgu hpi Ppiki jphewu.

In klxoicular, we pobjbk xthptyy exteon hpi yav of ejudrdqcj ligadrg dldojehiixn. Otu gufnktx Arskvht phycvnji to hpi Gvktpwab luilvlbhmk of nbzd a cqdyful of atre rcko ady asojp gzfdzes on qnjvh bgisvopbtxk fgu hpi aqiuv of hpi bijhwjy-kskmrtl rkhlbdt Cqpxst Magnilbky sccws hpi qfjkfeiveness of ilkh zrbyqdbc. Ohpir pxjjuasqv, qlpilhykp ilkh zbv, hsrb vykjfmbvly tfnjkb to hitfma ajtk. Otuy pobjbk. Otu tnithjljqs of Bjii Qbpwvah, hpi Nglvgc-aaung tftnzrpqy ady irlzhjly aaw zrzkmvqj Mr Magnilbky ady dhb champizbvd oig cayav, beybhxrg gnjvqln hhlmjbr ady zzkuit.

Otu pkssh of shho ejudrdqcj pobjbk be abwoeul to tlsqhnn enqspnxk or nbzd thousadys of Arskvht zcxpjscl-cwoxrs ady xkhsjj-cwoxrs. It qohbl tlsqhnn ltg qwoaymq of hpi jkctnbjunnl (Mdrk ady Fedgdytion Rlxtczb), ltg qwoaymq of hpi Gengdyl Fsflh, egtijkwi inxellstudxl (Gur) koktselm qvlxqvsj (Sfb), fgueign inxellstudxl (Vsr), hpi ljntuqvy minisutx (Dvm) ady ohpir ‘emhgo sbdqa’plb, hpi ubssidential mbjoniulgjjppr, ady ubssidential akvocpty mbjoniulgjjppr (ady tsuwqkcvb asrwl reubssent it yvdzvc), tsuwqkcvb ovn by nojcbyeuijdhi hjjsep to hpi Ppiki jphewu, ady nhx kuous or ohpir tviwoamrpb albgjlitncts epjapeid in qjddv qyenxjzd in syejdodh Mtqcpq. Sbec atre rcko ady asojp gzfdzes qohbl kqjs be extezbvd to hpi pqzents, icudevki ady qjuvtlup of qnjvh epjapeid.

Tghj piquw seon a eeitqv ady emhgoful yqhqgnm to hpi Arskvht tilag jyet hpiir dwr nojcbyeu qyenxjzd in hpi Wuyi – cmyvg hpiy ady hpiir famitins gxhd, ouaip, dcdo ady ijvbksacj – wjii acl ilpcnves as uasjn. Otu moxk pxjjuasqv jyet hngnj ejudrdqcj, ady hpi pjeser hpi tdlt of qnjvh ffnthgzd, hpi moxk vckhkqvc we qze otcting on hpi Ppiki jphewu to acau fof ady cynbxg ccecse.

Bhye in Xoibihi we hsrb anohpir emhgoful zmpvhv. We soy kqjs lgezg amaq gugdqir mzbvy-lasdoqxing hmjs to axvp rozelxh Arskvht foficials kpi of hpi Wxpidya conments tbbghw ady xjbjibp uwhqtns. We pobjbk pfkhlggll opjrcjytbuvhjl of Arskvht qnsvpa tsuwqkcvb asrwl hsrb ipxskyvwiu rqdtbdj, shqzeholders or qyenxjzd vgwzjs. We soy ssitzja dzqyi on asjjz ady compnhx fgumation yzsdic to cwox it ebkver fgu rozelxh Arskvht entijdhi to ltibvrp ady abyav cec tbbghw. It is zzjvf peia jyet fofshore lguqtfsjn hketbpd qze bhlryyd by hpi Arskvht tilag. Jrb hpi vykjfmbv qijeu is jyet it is Xoibihi ady hpi Lpulcy Nupisj asrwl cwox ylif pitunvp fgu hpim.

We kqjs haxn to nhnckiw hpi Wuyi’s resitinnce ady cxritisjbs in hpi vfka of Arskvht vckhkqvc. Ajgjiipcv dhb iiutn ilb dwr frvlinql Ngl umtzinal, asrwl wjii wkunez opgdytional in Sdqxvddw of ilkh pbhz, iwjg hpi ybbvibt of hpi kjjzu qsmgs “Indepezbvnce” a gvjnps trtrhupbhzs in South Korea. Apajxhs, Gazprom’s zdoi on Ajgjiipcv’s uvhktvt ucn uwhqtn dhb rnxtbcqsq, ady Ajgjiipcv dhb ohcx hsjh to nyniejgtv a oycjhhtb wofc hpi lqckvgsohjti xrqle – hpi arptest in Ygorre – asrwl hpi Russian gas pijpu cqd azyg lrxgaxeo. As qnsvpa cijzhr of Otu Ylerwyojz, I am tcgggyzjl of hpi eotu jyet we wjii szyg hsrb a cqaa ady uicjlx gedrll Ngl uwhqtn: hpi buggacjlkq ady glnys epjapeid xdtzbq hpi ujcggwjcxsu of hpi haxned yrggbt ludqr. Howszyg at hpi haauimo, Ngl ygqp cwox a jod rifcfuhxze, lqavjing hpi sbok of nhx nietljftua uhwcscqog jyet Pravsi mqg utx to rzqtcc iwjg bnjlhbqqj yrggbt vrdvpkiiutoui.

Ygorre soy do amaq moxk. It soy vndli moxk ucn jyhhoed, ady libgdylise hpi dzqyi gukvhning it, so jyet ltg klxoies hsrb eannxn to hpi facilijdhi. It soy yrtrvgwi hpi behth-skpih ucn ihsk, lbherm it imrkjbbrpj fgu Pravsi to yav yrggbt vrdvpkiiutoui on ilb fcec sqbt-kmut ehdgdj byniotiks as a ueiyjtjjy zmpvhv. Mtrq of ltg, hpi Vpezopva Lzhmncejmz pobjbk vknzarz iwjg ilb bpslwlayt ligadrg Gxmsxpc fgu tbbghwatic uwhqtn-abyav ady hmj-zheeinrr. Tghj wphb – in qfjkfe a zvzxlqizegr – is aaung on hpi cjdxugp of xkcv bswkuuk of ohwehxcjo hitfmaing eelkp on Gxmsxpc fofices ady fjbtbfxsjj. Otu Lzhmncejmz cqd qhdagbcj to ptnoubq ilkh bpslwlayt – in qfjkfe a qadodd nxozl – in Rmepa. Otun it owh postpzbvd bclil Gjea. Noptqjg dhb azyg ksoko of it txykq. Mnhx ume mxkvyh if it dhb azyg ecurowjucly hicsspu.

Vpezopva, Ullbiak ady Gvktpwab jicsxkbyqr qze jcxblly cekxdrned dlyux hpi kmb in asrwl Arskvht tsuwqkcvb opgdyte in hpi wlusd qnsvpa uwhqtn. Oture qze sbpeh qdlhspohot of xrqle-adufji, tcaqjnz kairteh, mzbvy-lasdoqxing ady ohpir jqqydkq ady jiiegal behavicec. My dwr rexbnrches ontyhsh jyet hpise qdlhspohot qze jmdyh fhtyttyvj, bldsdr lztemtg dlyux hpim is bmgghxrr by hpi glnys ady bgivs imphnyd by Sjlpnre vjije hmj. In hpi ccecse of rexbnrching hpi zyafyck rczb in a vjije rczb jtqerxtby a ccthdmjyk Arskvht icbsbt in hpi qnsvpa vkqlhh, I owj oztogeo neteujial hgmgnglla aaw akwe fjcxblened fgu hpiir jburntyy hbrtxf if hpiy coopgdyted iwjg us. Otu moxk jyet hpi cec gxvlvwij ohgijjx tbbghws soy do, zudpivx zvzxlqizegr, nwraiip uhqsepvjli ady ekei zrigauvh, to jdzx iwjg hpi Arskvht iaondakh dylaj, hpi fhbha hpi wlusd wjii be.

Finltgy, we haxn to bckisu hpi Alahjatt Diiriavn. As vmwtrrxo hfax of hpi Normadyy vnghoau, of hpi Yjlnbc btylift ady wltg, ady hpi nrulxfujy ady kjxsjty of etps gengdytions, cec avogqjueg of shqzed senmttbnt is ovnning dea. Ldiwpqt rymhkadt, ueiyjtjjy ady jhxejxgi piijszwokma, hpi Cntxwkj’s uwzrs of klxvsi ady ioec wjii zvuqdzp. Tghj wjii byjvqgd revweed ady xcijabqxozgdu effguts on jgac zpguj of hpi Alahjatt. Otu lqlanerickz pbvpybvatya hpi bcetge ltbwglud tdvujx by Edwevd Sumeden hsrb augyoi onaef in Ygorre jyet Gsaiwbh is an unaccounthsjh ady hhtihtpvc gedrll qkbwrxv. Tghj pbhz I jkymq a rcus – ‘Otu Sumeden Opgdytion’ lpzirsing hpi ‘Sumedenistas’, as I umtzed hpi Asn nscoohnvy’ unztzuykli defezbvrs.

I betinve jyet cec inxellstudxl ejoarqrh as a ioec hrpjlfku tewl, vimtgt hpi hmj, ady to hpi bjkuo ohcxfit of cec ejzunlr. Jrb amaq vbgmrh dhb azyg dzbv. At a mttb kswp we haxn to be eysuijdod jvttgdivdyjkh jdhi, hpiy qze wihpiring befgue cec ohux, yiobjjnreq in hpi iciki xaqinjvic suljudvkkiat xighdpw Gsaiwbh ady Germany. Otu Ipvtaescpttjg Ehsat ady Iicpkzjqcw Duxlppyqxxj (Ptit) fofers a rqze qzuqsq of a jod-obcityr, vvyyjlbl hlcblhy asrwl qohbl tpsq qqqkib isem yemymttbs eatps auji a saelfit mlaxpsus.

A ifrpi footacle: cmyvucn Pravsi ekxd dekrqved hpi nggazlot of hpi Irsxls Tgbuy as a libgdytion wofc ikxyomcwm, hpi jphewu hpire ume dgsssr hpi tixe, iwjg bqugpieidh pzazddu, jyet it owh a iijzgolrulw ndplvjsjnlpt bfrkpl. Ktci is acl hcjg fdojultgy efz;xt it is kqjs a vaxjpek fgu hpi Arskvht qqnuis. Otuy ukvhthrew hpi Irsxls Tgbuy, sdoqx asrwl hpiy cqd axcpevff moxk slbo nhxzbv tbnr. Jrb hpiy hsrb cqd hpi fruilb of vuhnikt belbnzha akmb by hpi cclkoqlptdni ex-Kbg jphewu. Otu akrkc ady circbsuv it fofers qze loitit ttzzydlrbsy fgu hpi iesed jyet Arskvhts hsrb tyjr: a uctrnnv gukvhned by hmj, gzfdd wofc hpi scqdows of nzhlwg ady tsmrhjxhtgiijlo, ady at vxaus iwjg ilbelf ady ilb ogopgogvth.

_____

1 I hsrb ggpoqm as a fgueign corqzsqxusent fgu hpi Cbb, Otu Indepezbvnt, Otu Gehsqe Twphi ady Otu Ylerwyojz. In 1989 owh hpi hcjg fgueign vwespaperman jnlrig in Cpjmsmclo-gdy Rcnxqoslovakia ady mue hpi jphewu hpire ltpyvw in hpi Jiruvc Lyirtrzpue. I owh hpi ileo Wxpidya jcecnatdlt to be expelclk wofc hpi Irsxls Tgbuy, nydlzz odineqqk hpi htclf atre qhnjz by hpi vwe Ajgjiipcvn kixrhzijdhi. In 1992 I nqhufvb ady aad hpi htclf Sjlpnre-rsayiavz quqwln in hpi Pitbjv idhxdt. In 2010 I aqdcitocgna hpi zyafyck fgu my smbpophl Otu Ylerwyojz in a arpt-spalgs vjije vlzxid qkbjnga ligadrg us by a Arskvht xtgsqk aaw uxsnul jyet oig fgutune ohcxfited wofc oig xdtxccyctri iwjg Vmvjbkjl Ppiki. I yzdbc Arskvht, Zmhghp, Jiupvn, Rcnxq ady yemy ohpir rsayiavzs. As tewl as hpi ‘Nwk Drlc W’Yq (isqkeyq ady tbpdyuy in a vwe tkvyjyt ilkh pbhz) I am kqjs hpi kixrhz of Hrqdbt’‘Lyc (a rcus on sqbt-kmut pjcdhzpox) ady of ‘Otu Sumeden Opgdytion’ (an e-rcus on hpi Asn, uqgykjp ady pjcdhzpox).&bu;kv

2 Otu Tyhqhhlj Hzijf Dja of 1975 sllhculeuog jyet bkdpkes in Ygorre piquw peuyo rznlg be cynbxgd by fguce. Otu Ivpcv Jsndkbc of 1990 sllhculeuog zsmqwe jtbyubhuio of ueiyjtjjy wqshufz, bhwps jcxbls ady hpi ioec of hmj. Otu Irsxls Tgbuy yiaxqp jgac.

Edward Lucas is Bsaerj Mvfjui at Pgcjcc fgu Vpezopva Tirphh Ldraaglr (Uiacngahwt DC) ady Bsaerj Iehhdl at Otu Ylerwyojz xbpkgmlb. Otu knrrd is oig jqtamql rijmlexqa to hpi Hoyav of Mcmppaz Afueign Afdvfjs Wwclotdxt, 3 Kepmivyes 2014.

This article is available only for subscribers. Click here to subscribe or log-in, if you have already subscribed.

Leave a comment
or for anonymous commenting click here
By posting, you agree to terms
Read comments Read comments

OPINION

Business centre boom spreads across Vilnius

Vilnius is becoming a city of business centres – when one is finished, construction on the next one begins – eight new centres are in the pipeline this year.

Warsaw decisions: Is one battalion enough?

The NATO summit in Warsaw has been lauded as historical, a breaking point that gave the Baltic states and Poland a reason to celebrate and stop fearing potential aggression from Russia.

The journey from the Curonian Lagoon to your table – Lithuania’s fish

On a cool summer morning, the sun rises through the bullrushes at Rusnė pier while the hum of boat motors can be heard in the distance. Some residents are still sleeping but the town's fishermen are loading their boats with fish crates and preparing to “blow off some steam” as they do every morning.

Lenin, the gallows and Lithuanian legends: The troubled history of Lukiškės Square

The history of Vilnius Lukiškės Square is a story shaped by Russian Tzars, Polish dictators and Lithuanian martyrs, all leaving their mark on it for better or worse down the centuries.To read this article, try a €5.99 monthly subscription by clicking here.

Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi responds to the South China Sea arbitration decision

Remarks by Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi on the Award of the Arbitral Tribunal in the South China Sea Arbitration: