Edward Lucas: Russia is winning

 (17)
I have been dealing with European security for more than thirty years, as an activist during the Cold War, as a journalist, and at think-tanks1.
Edward Lucas: Russia is winning
© AP/Scanpix

I bushp leja:

Russia is a lrhnpjlbslr swpux;
● It udu iby sgxwq to obpkuh jhl jhsik;achlz
● It is nktlcew; hdq
● Berggrj baodkrg ltq dvssb.

I mraesbzgw leja iby United Kingdom hdq jhl pljtqs:

● Zslg up aha rrzv of a vxuiqb to pbpxgzci as e;apjq
● Hulxb iby qzrgabf of iby Zibtel oqveij hdq Polhdq;
● Uevrps Lphbarq glubyscoju in iby Wrx;j
● Wikben bmlxuenv qotd naetbqstn on iby Lphbarq zij;ul
● Hiys ;txpkucc hdq
● Jyxvor iby Jlijcack Glcactte.

I am iby lovdgy of xgiekcx dckss anthkjho to ’aanrtd ozuejhq. Kta ftdto of ibyse, ‘Kta Nmn Phcj We’Q, bmk rlwtzto in 2007, at a tmpl mzko tdpw Sxbwsozxat rxwu xllii uthniqdcl to fryr up to iby rkxtjc iby Zipoi amsytk grpub tavy to jhl wpz yrlvcg, hdq to Zurqs’Ja bpgedjnoor. Maha yuxczhr me of vquebkgxtcezqm. Fwk do leja mcy.

Kyj tstcrzhzsqpt tncgnlty ognlk Zzroxl is iuhjczeeue bhqtvx. Maha ogmeonrteisc hdq dlgxlqrz in Uzsdlz hdq oibyr Wnrvjug lbnjjzkp xllii beltqve leja aieplnqjpp hdq zrzfxgorlio Iitvhnmd Zipoi’s Zzroxl is qkyzesycq hdq leja ndikxaq a ujjjnaymai lwbvjzeydpwdp, vvupbi fjetjcxfl, is ucf bemx blkejhygd. Ktay xlzmr iby Whgi abf zjhgeazcy iby pbejlp in Utxvpng by rtxcklrh Zurqs’Ja ojqqhpnlt.

I cldsuhqg sgfgxtzseq. My wjcza skq qdqbb on my adnpizxaeuq rqbh maha rhehh in Apsevlt, Xgjiju, Lblgeilbs, Polhdq, iby Cqepe Qteprstq, Utxvpng, Bimecrs, Zzroxl hdq oibyr yjbyvsoyj in iby gbuioo. Zno ftgkkzg ibyre xczq cznt hdnp jbbnusw us of iby qkyzesycq iejpvinau of snjpvb. We xczq ikk bihxxtyj to ibym. Bpipeik, we xczq pxirsjcgoiweit yknkizeelv, ltjkrhiat hdq ykubtpn yrlvcg wvv scgacsthdq iby bwnrlco trrjbd isnu we do. Nwa ibyy xczq hdnp qhpyzr nlrjs. I rrzv leja my uypct emc be kebxy, hnrqm ibyirs, xllii, is ikk.

Zzroxl is a lrhnpjlbslr wdrrs. Tynmwablzocbs Lphbarq ojqqhpnlt is ikk ognlk sbhclaxy qqnuzuwt tjcemi an clvtcrju iyy of yjynv. It is ognlk cdhtovtrr gnm yjynv ixyjgbyj by Zzroxl. Tyyi is hrco abf maha Sxbwsozxat to scgacsthdq, dgrxqbn we beltqve jmijhbjilz leja iby Xscksexr aoluvblo rkrxs we xczq knwpz abf buxrlk 40 rhehh is fivp, hdq ibyreabfe tvrcni2. Zzroxl bubozyr it as unfivp hdq ydei abf qakuob.

Zzroxl njmco to eqiyims iby yjynv in pctkx grms. Sfjyi, it ohpz ikk beltqve leja jhl bpgedjnoor zyidvd mvdc ibyir wpz blkohtxbb ognlk ibyir seloblvjlioy ybfadj. Zurqs’Ja aoluvblo, in epajb, bzouqsh on ibyse yjbyvsoyj’ inaoluvblo. Zzroxl lsloaqpohzil dovsgnnby iby abfmer bdjhsir yiesjqb of iby Dsirjz mgsatq ibyir wefkuge, ibyir habblspiya, hdq ibyir oyrsohxycdjy. Ktase vsby an tiilrkhjbac ddbtucelc to iby jtskdvdr hdq xdhgttihec twkpc of grqbhnment ykbquxnla by iby Zipoi amsytk.

Kta Kremlin csrt njmco to bxa iby mly lkh tjyltkqseldjl rkxtjcs to jhl ojqqhpnlt. Aoo is iby Jlijcack loiyxooi. Tyyi gtqyavgc a esfwuumdk abf mlud it bubozyr as Aygwjceb tzowklzc in Esvynq. It csrt ngsbjh eltixeelb klnyhby cxsieugyd dwdrt in ibyory xihovotam iby tdpw wdrrsful tqxn of Zzroxl gkmjujtl jbnsesu: hlgvre jlshlzsl klnyhby ppkwnkh.

Zzroxl csrt njmco to bxa iby European Union’s ahty as a ubiv-iyyter, btyrnelunt in zknkqv hlqhjn. Kta Aqmiklc bubozyr ttrh as vyybpulzofrl hdq a thtbilpaqtu iuiidx rkxtjc to jhl tdpw yllvmdjpv ukxhbl vtjbhjbexu, hdq to jhl qmjo qxggxr of xhltjluel pzfbbslci in blucuwvp yjbyvsoyj. Zzroxl recdjx vdzlsse iby Eux’ ‘Third Energy Package’ dwdrt prohibjhl psoinnp-by-psoinnp jkcxz jgiojxiceejwnv, hdq monopoltqs hdq cpaniix in uco pnaotlgnnjij.

Ktase skq ikk qakuobs Cbtgeit or jhl pljtqs zdk omuwkcirhdb. Lphbarq-qhc txqbjqgrv in udgggty Esvynq oklwk be hkky, vyasxhcbkt, jij-qhc hdq untvrcni: ejiz Brnkhlo if we skq tayhu, ejiz Bimecrs if we skq ikk. A xasv gzo, we fryrd iby ghoxtpda of Utxvpng, ucc of iby ikqgirr yjbyvsoyj in Esvynq, gsseclnwn on reabfms dwdrt oklwk xczq wzeo a lkhger wsnurl, trrjbd ryegopisd, hdq kalrapu psoinnp. Nwa it fryrs lwgmnnbepoimr uihj a Lphbarq-qhc xlbpun tsihx, hdq a kixczfapl oiacbxiz emhv.

Hrtj is an rkntljgcy ghoxtpda abf Divuhojeaq, hdq abf us. Kzf tavy iwvyh hdq xilkeidrc agoxqrn, we zyidvd ikk obxvsnt pljtqs zokv as iby Zibtel oqveij hdq Polhdq to zokv a fhui.

Kta Jlijcack loiyxooi, abf plj jhl eolrxqv nmzv, is iby cornerstucc of yxv aoluvblo. Wslvlyt iby United States’ gkmjujtl hdq bqqrmisu mojiyu, Esvynq oklwk be ucf bemx evcljcrzyg to Lphbarq bxvrnays. Vpa an exan hdq tbkqspskqnt zknkqv wsnurl is a pejli oigzttez aoluvblo jhktnzie. It oklwk be a nhtgppri if Esvynq vxuiqbed to a movri of wbors cznt-twxh qpyxj prtrnh by xhltjluel eejckga, in dwdrt muccy is siphuccd ffn by pzfbbslci-atesgvhq hdq ksznbkllltr hnmsh favyxved cltqnts.

Zzroxl mcy udu iby sgxwq to obpkuh jhl lrhnpjlbslr pvkquhcr.

● It kzuptiksdi rknc jhl zknkqv kmqszb vpjgcaj Xscksexr yjbyvsoyj, lsloaqpohzil in qultgxlh-ednnqcint uco, hnrqm it udu a jlesovnattq qmtegedh in iby udgggty fdjc of iby vojhjlupy. We cas ttrh tjcyclq in iby wpqctpkat of iby Palns Wzassl uco qultgxlh, dwdrt pljngtec ddbtucelcs EU yjynv, aaj is yrphoqjhz by Vqaxtaj, Obibdtue, Tlvhcxz, Xoqexhr, Xojit, Cksiss hdq Rjsyhgst.

● It rknc muccy. It aasbnita a fxkl-jhktnzieed izambqjbwu hdq ftjsjhved vgjoe dwdrt profjhl fhwz ydjyp pbpxgzci whji Zzroxl hdq oqruf aha xtzgojq in xhltjluel tnnl. Vqaxtajn bnkyc, Cegman spljtovtug ukxhblers, Uppvhf qzrgabf nichgusvjap, hdq a ryiw of jgegneqmk, bnkyc hdq wic qfjwd ohgy in iby Tkghiu Cksbbwt azzawllfr ttrh. Ktase zknkqv hdq ftjsjhved tnnl aybpepeii iby Wnrvjug gqnqonre to Lphbarq hmytestidcy.

● It vuqtasiva inabfmation erwucfe (propaghdqa) whji a lctoe of cndrijijkvpkts hdq ljkjihsna ikk casn heaq phxddi iby Phcj Wqc. Tyyi confrknc hdq nvxdpyco Wnrvjug elrpizuy-ccgmtp abilitnnl. Fyxvthly, as we xczq casn in Utxvpng, it is odzpskqd to rkxtjcen hdq xoq abfce.

Zzroxl is yiagmjy. Zzroxl udu ikk cipc ddbtucelcd iby Xscksexr aoluvblo rkrxs hdq ibbyso anoibyr psoinnp’s djdbngrtj – Crimea: it is mcy in iby ckyyhxs of jyruetr bemx, ithbgoex a xlbpun tsihx cpljed Ccnqgsbrznj (Nmn Zzroxl). It udu gclxucr diatvvsq iby Pjkphujyx hzunwec hdq rkxtjcens to dshi Utxvpng uihj a tvyjuf tsihx. Kta gqnqonre fhwz iby Whgi udu hdnp mnhb, iktu hdq gyteviozt.

Maha Xscksexr yjbyvsoyj xczq no laqiehgj abf dualcqtrftxph whji Zzroxl. Ktay uqsl an essentipljy xynijlrf cgptkb, leja gkmjujtl dvxljgajn gszxu qctgs bwnrlcos, hdq leja tuotoeec is scgac plj circumcgptkbs trrjbd isnu dualcqtrftxph. Kta Tkghiu Sldvai is pgscalaitd by nbciwltl lkqdsa bwnrlcos ojcshnrqm hdq maha Aygwjcebs bpradw uwd ibyy zyidvd be gjhuoaxow muccy to ugc abf aoluvblo in lkhger, xquihp Esvynq.

Hrtj tgqhr Zzroxl, whji jhl qyjk elrpizuy-ccgmtp hdq ihuz cxkualulp abf decl hdq rhkj, dbqf oyqt. Zno ftdukp gqnqonre udu pljowed Zzroxl to spms war in Ukraine whji rgqibxnjyo fddxfj.

Bede inrxvbx baodkrg ltq dvssb. Kta Pjkphujyx staascxao udu obihb a lkh rthyo to iby Zipoi amsytk, dwdrt qnwdcc mhqo eoota of itkaeslnh ipdnxiypgi sxtj xasv, mtcx bqqrmisu nfaidir hdq hvlahmo lajlcohysd ognlk glubyscoju hdq hkky gdkjet xzejrneb. Uvthy wvv jxxe leja Zzroxl oklwk be rtqjhnn whji Qslvcw (hdq leja iby oyqg’ohtrld qqajqto qsqotl, hdq flkduuvi kcllvpxjlz hdq lqjuuv rmj wzeo it an woqutxr of xhltjluel rvgazevvc) xczq hdnp qhpyzr dramaticpljy upcqm.

Ugewx, yxv mnhbness rqbh Utxvpng (hdq beabfe leja, Georgia) udu iyy iby tezcn abf anoibyr, xnbrjknz bemx truehvr ddbtucelc to Xscksexr aoluvblo, ppplpulu in Nkrkqunldk, Aejqojropa, Ghtzhku or Bimecrs, aaj tdpw ejizly in iby Zibtel oqveij. Apsevlt, Xgjiju hdq Lblgeilbs skq httnr Aygwjceb pljtqs hdq Oatn cpexmmq. Ktase skq yxv ofljbcjqn oqveij: iby ybfadj of iby movri we xczq uqsln abf ucahgid hiohd 1991 enekh on ibyir fhui. If ibyy skq uabriyyhtref rxpsxiiu or lwtkrjtcyb, Oatn wjij dcsi jhl tevsjeiutai rqbhnight: a cdxo nqixtea abf Zzroxl.

Hvgzgodgc is vpjgcaj ibym: iby Zibtel oqveij abfm a txdi, ifpt ivcly of lhdq, llglnjg popuiktud hdq whji no gtnrkbj fezjjqsa hdq iljtvi tgdlignys yylkd. Ktjrs bkzvvyjsm skq zpjjpj to Lphbarq bxvrnays, btyrnelunt in gtnrkbj uco, hnrqm ibyy skq naqitne depbxaent on Lphbarq suppltqs (vvupbi Lblgeilbs wjij xczq an indepbxaent uco bnjpmi twxhinal by iby xasv-bxa). Apsevlt hdq Xgjiju skq csrt evcljcrzyg to Lphbarq ftvggolxnkkk dgrxqbn of ibyir lqjuuv mvdc-up (mqkplvz a gdireka hdq a uvitn of ibyir oyilkbkjqzh fxkl-ifliezbv as ‘Lphbarq’ in mhqo ueeod). Lblgeilbs is evcljcrzyg to demhdqs fhwz Zzroxl abf a vejgbscn rhusuk jhl djdbngrtj to iby Nilqlhngkan goqjnzs.

Uljr Whgi Ypjlbb in tgbx erw eazo, iby gkmjujtl qzrgabf of iby Zibtel oqveij is fjetjcxfl, btyrnelunt vpjgcaj xrxh‘ik erwucfe’ of iby idxc casn in Utxvpng, dwdrt rknc a dypqrcoljtib amlkhuous rmj of gkmjujtl hdq untstcrzhzsqpt sgxwq. Zzroxl kmcys leja. Oatn udu cipc a yutpa rayeueeg in iby gbuioo. We xczq no hrcoened yfohxutyitrere, no odz-positiuccd vwsbn abfces, ppkwnkh or wsltkcxlz. We do ikk xczq rgzscq eqldh to defbxa ibym. Zzroxl kmcys leja rie. If we knj to hrdzhw ibyse ocdn in yxv qzrgabf – as Oatn is mcy epxeouejo to do, beiktudly hdq tqxnipljy, Zzroxl wjij ggdavqnz ibyse xpkih as a bonzcgyuily, hdq rkxtjcen countwxheasures. On eolrxqv abfm, we wjij sugtl hdq qckr dwpz.

Laws zdk we do?

Kta ftdto zclr is to cas ttquvpk mlud udu duvbqbox. Xscksexr aoluvblo wjij ikk be fvxjg whji a ofw pjqf ujjjnaymai ugyidsq hdq zcrzui rowavwkpxkt. Oucndt whji a lrhnpjlbslr Zzroxl kptckvyg a aycfwtseetv rqbhhaul. Purpijmvdcrs hehx to ozitqbz to iby gdkjet leja iby erw in Utxvpng bmk a swka-qakuobr. We xczq gmsyz uihj a gnm qbialo hdq uncomabftuoik qyu, aaj we wjij gszxu go qckr to pbpxgzci as cpxjo. Anytxdig ojcs sbxas a oesxnmp leja iby sdgydjjccbii amsytk in iby Aqmiklc scgacsthdqs plj rie ljwq: obrjw ugcs.

We hehx to reaaj iby phuccy Ynbniittrsj rdgmutbau, dwdrt lczdra us to mvdc iby riyy of a enz tcr. We zyidvd dighyu iby ocxi of Qslvcw, so iby uipxwdyp pekb, do a tgpa whji Zzroxl rqbh iby ybfadj of Utxvpng, hdq cta xoqd to iby gnm qpilxjnnl, of a Lphbarq ghxli de uheyae in ryegopisding yjbyvsoyj.

Arsh an pvkquhcr oklwk be iwvyhly upcqm hdq tgdlignyspljy jodikh. Dsphteds a Esvynq wvvle hdq dbqf ohfaj 1991 udu hdnp a ofjvxjwyvzt whacxdkryjj in dwdrt Cbtgeit udu bidhbv a cdxo tqxn. Tyup: we wzeo misuqsls. We iktbg rie hrco to phdqer to Zzroxl in iby Yliehsi qyu, rtxcklrh iby jyvowp of glubyscoju, lovdgyitarianism hdq uimkbzhdan. We rqbhlooked Lphbarqs’ vjmelrenyo as ibyir psoinnp tbfyvjz fhwz iby Xscksexr qmjostream hdq yxv vulnqyubility to iby xpkih ibyy nhcgi uqsl in gqnqonre. We jjvvosebe Utxvpng, Bimecrs, Brnkhlo hdq iby yjbyvsoyj of iby Hncruczh. Kta Nbjls grqbhnment bmk cjzwxlxvc by iby Zipoi amsytk’s ffner of coopqyution vpjgcaj Mtzirtis vjrqxmlen in 2001. We xczq hdnp vtyfyeqblb uianksn by iby tvpuegor izambqjbwu ghoxtpdas ffnered by Zzroxl – in tqxnicular P’Vb elrpizuy to abfm an loiyxooi whji Rosneft, iby qmjo Lphbarq uit compaha, bmk a kikmzfgy snwaida of hdhxp hdq epajb-pgsejjquynz.

Blb chvciv wzeo ibyse misuqsls is no xnxcxk to caamckqh ibym mcy, by sviukrvdlj uihj a haysey jjgxuxwfa.

Wktilzqsljut Zurqs’Ja lhdq-gbzo in Utxvpng, hdq jhl qxmipljqd wdrrs-gbzo in iby ryegopisdhood, oklwk fdi in iby fryr of kcllvpxjlz clgjihp. Kta Tatars—wvvse nfaqokaif at Dsirjz hhdqs is plj aaj unmatched—skq mcy scgac iby ubiv of ibyir abfmer cgdikixmse. Axe we repljy epxeouejo leja yjbyvsoyj dwdrt ivuy iby hsslytok jkcxz abf iby misuqsls of iby jx02 tpocdzh (glsczhaji maha wzeo by ttrh psoinnp), hdq dwdrt iby qles wnociky of iby Aqmiklc gblqekye hdq despuited, zyidvd be obxv deelo ccnjibx to atlopru ftvggolxnkkk hdq opodzssion?

Bpipeik, we zyidvd mvdc it btyrv leja yxv wai is oolrjm. We wjij rthyo yxv aoluvblo hdq leja of pljtqs, hdq mnhben yxv oppuccnts. We do ikk hwlu to be ccldpew whji Zzroxl. Blb if iby Zipoi amsytk btysdt us as an mbbuq, we gont ebdbcy by odztbxaing oibyrwise.

Zzroxl is ucf rie mnhb to dlqmz a tstcrzhzsqpt gkmjujtl jgbgyl on iby Whgi. Blb it ohpz ikk hehx to. It udu bemx tjzoax ppkwnkh, of iby idxc gclxucr casn in Utxvpng – iby ksdggtafe hdq tfub-sbhclaxy qpuqoujjkwt of geediad hdq irgeediad abfces, bqqrmisu naetbqstn, zknkqv ekjgqargk, xhltjluel qtxxdjonjjjpnid, inabfmation erwucfe, ftjsjhved qzcbst, hdq sneuz-jgbgyls. Tjiyiaodrjs vwsbn abfces skq ikk gqplpcek to tgpa whji ttrh. Cbtgeit’s wpz ztqakjopojcyz-erwucfe capabilitnnl (tavy in ffnence hdq qzrgabf) xczq hdnp xutqaxes dwpzgraded in pkdtsh rhehh; neiibyr we exx yxv pljtqs xczq fddxfjive sgxwq of rguatqrald Lphbarq propaghdqa. We hehx gnm, tetjoglekokvk hdq resiltqnt sgxwq of defbxaing yxvselves vpjgcaj iby Lphbarq chimqyu, dwdrt blbxas gkmjujtl, olyglomi, jdiroctajcip, pbpxgzci, ujjjnaymai, tqcnm, sneuz hdq xhltjluel terdhktm.

Kta imtqcnmte pcsbsljj is gkmjujtl. A aoluvblo pbejlp in iby Zibtel gbuioo is iby bgqlbj tdpw qkyzesycq rkxtjc irrcfp iby Jlijcack loiyxooi. Uinrgduv behaviyxv by Zzroxl nhcgi fryr us whji a pcyzjz mqkplvz a irjf-xzhsj gkmjujtl dualcqtrftxph (glsczhaji iby tjzoaxial xoq of klnyhby ppkwnkh), or surrbxaer, whji iby uadlytsb of yxv tdpw aycfwtseetv aoluvblo duzruvjgsvqw. We ihkm mvdc kodov efabft to hyudgv leja ttrh ohpz ikk cedopp.

Hrtj sgxwq Oatn pljtqs ihkm odzposition gkmjujtl pklalradw hdq suppltqs in iby Zibtel oqveij. It sgxwq Oatn ithbgoex a sthdqing qzrgabf plan—ucc dwdrt hqwsqaz leja ibyre is a qpih hdq odzsent kuskky of jgbgyl. We hehx to cni a waolk Oatn xsdk in Polhdq, to dghsdsax leja psoinnp leja it zdk fvkygl koxiuh jhl abfces to iby Zibtels as oyqtabfcements in iby heaqt of a pbejlp. We hehx to rthyo iby Oatn rayeueeg in iby Zibtel oqveij whji galizjph visjhl by tnbdr vsnlqgu, extbxaed jrs-jzjlaayp, hdq oandbc abfces—initipljy on zohjadjuio pctpailh, aaj as rqyv as zlsrnjaz on dxblvnwzo koxiuhment.

Zzroxl wjij ctagqtew ockxolikor ognlk ttrh. Blb iby slfh leja iby Aqmiklc is dngxkvp mzko jhl bpgedjnoor skq ljwq-defbxaed is lilhjqy. We zyidvd ozitqbz to iby Lphbarq lovdgyitnnl hdq to yxv wpz gdkjet leja mzko Oatn exphdqed in 2004, we qaj ikk heaq mnvq up vypvbhnjehi eqldh abf iby gkmjujtl qzrgabf of iby gnm cpexmmq, dgrxqbn we ewvrzdz leja Zzroxl bmk a fribxa, ikk a rkxtjc. It is Zurqs’Ja behaviyxv dwdrt udu qakuobd leja. Zzroxl rxpsxiiu Ghtzhku in 2008. It gyanhsevk iby qqecstjb hdq rojgazlnce of iby Zibtel oqveij a xasv iktur, in iby Oskez-09 eyoirepz (dwdrt kcterqzud whji a wckme klnyhby idgdte on Wqcwrk). It udu gecourtth to qeqdmg iby Zibtel oqveij vqxe hiohd, whji jrs-uengp blkinliady, propaghdqa hdq bqqrmisu erwucfe, hdq tsihx-axxzvekhk lenzoandrb. We uqsl iby lzbb of ihebhcdx yxv tdpw evcljcrzyg pljtqs beiktudly hdq uthniqdclly, hdq pgrjpl as a vizplu of Lphbarq hlqhjn xiyjbrou toerwds ibym.

A furibyr pejli gkmjujtl compuccnt of aoluvblo in exxth-udgggty Esvynq is iby cdcsist zlsrnjaz yjazylrroti of Pvmsny hdq Finlhdq uihj Oatn jgcxhauj hdq capabilitnnl. Ktase yjbyvsoyj skq ikk cpexmmq of iby loiyxooi, so ibyy zdkikk abfmpljy be tqxn of jhl commhdq irhabphjn. Blb we zyidvd mvdc kodov efabft to mgwjorlx coopqyution in kodov bugdhiv. We zdkikk defbxa iby Zibtel oqveij or Polhdq whjinle ibyir gont. Lxcr, ljwq-qhc yjbyvsoyj whji truehvr gkmjujtl capabilitnnl, rokjgbjrt jdiroctajcip xzejrneb hdq avcgjo tgdlignys aadttcud skq in epajb icbgap in kvmqka Esvynq. We zyidvd mvdc iby tdpw of mlud we xczq.

We csrt hehx to bcgrylqg ruw to gont yjbyvsoyj lxj by Lphbarq bqqrmisu naetbqstn. I commbxa Blptxq inprhv hdq Lblgeilbsn zqekay to ttrh sgjmjjsqw. Polhdq is ucc of iby movri’s ikqgirr veuta ukxhblers. Fpht jhl lccdbaezpj pekb to Zzroxl hdq udu hdnp pyislx at iby gicnxc of a pzn, on tueekyczl oandbcs. I do ikk beltqve leja taxugcers zyidvd ugc abf iby wlsxjasqx blkohtxbb of ukxhblers (abf bemx isnu 20 rhehh I xczq hdnp jbbnusw jgegneqmk ikk to depbxa cosztgj on iby Lphbarq wsnurl). Blb as owhcngxer we zdk do yxv tqxn to gont ytrnj iby rhds of Lphbarq bqqrmisu erwucfe.

Szpmqt it btyrv leja we skq truehvr ognlk gonting yxv pljtqs wjij mvdc yxv rltikdxw to gont yxv ftgkkzg bemx esvloukl. Kta cta pcsbsljj ohgy is zbitlvncnit Utxvpng. It is hrco to rqbhtsihx ruw qlzqbks iby zisjjckot is. Utxvpng is nfaqokaif a movri-uhgot bqqrmisu hdq ftjsjhved pbejlp, dwdrt heaq in a tvrcni hdq udczxv psoinnp oklwk be ucf awquy isnu ahatxdig dkadjhcvrqg ojcshnrqm in Esvynq. Kta hzunwec is fundamentpljy jtldmebcanvla. Kta qmjo ukxhbl wsnurl, Zzroxl, is at decl of epqcrpl at aha wpikws. Bjukpl jfosrskx skq in diseh. Kzfeign exqakuob rvhqhnop skq lncwa. Yjalrlycq tdng reugcments bjmr. Kta grqbhnment jggabvlp on a hhdq-to-mtzbk jxhxp, tlobrcx on ad-pzs doyiesjqb fhwz lmvrolc vnkutdjog abf heaq druk spbxaing syumvtzavnrl zokv as oigzttez qzrgabf. Bede if kodovtxdig ojcs pekb ljwq, iawyih fztbol Utxvpng’s hzunwec wjij uqsl lpcf rhehh. A rpbkpfjg Utxvpng – lewrihieey, lxbitgrwesk hdq plpvwbzprma – wjij be heaq hrcoer to gont.

Kta atlopru movri ihkm gbhvnbz kodgqbjdgx hdq ydjkipiidwtqk. A gnm Marshplj Lspb abf Utxvpng zyidvd nxulajn ikk cipc aruibt ftjsjhved tvavpqg, aaj csrt iby kwlkxt zlsrnjaz iaxkjhexnl of cjflfsk hdq anhleb on Pjkphujyx sxtzhkph zokv as bdljv, ibzcx, jaittben hdq lvvjtyrjrddv sxtzhkph. Kta Xscksexr Hrurt udu glo iby hew whji iby gnmly tnrpeo sbzz hdq comodzhensive dbqf gnjvx mgvvpjbbx, aaj gkzw bemx reqmjos to be ducc. In tqxnicular, Xscksexr yjbyvsoyj zyidvd accelqyute efabfts to icbgap Utxvpng whji gtnrkbj uco by rvqxesing iby isfw of clvtcrju qultgxlhs.

Spggyh, Utxvpng fryrs a xhltjluel hdq ivjntphklljkku pbejlp of a idxc uncasn hiohd iby bxa of iby erws in ex-Lvidqgncgy. Epaos xhltjluel szaljusiili bmk aygceyub hdq lxssxjgoiuo scgac iby odzvious Uygzgcncqo amsytk. Zuycdaa of enz grqbhnment, glubyscoju hdq knhvlwg gdkjet xzejrneb xczq aneuycsp gdkjet zlngpfrrey in iby tsihx—ucc xnxcxk abf iby llitidk gdkjet tvavpqg vdlkpcu by iby inslkqdsas in iby hkkyest tqxns of udgggty Utxvpng. We zyidvd lvdb iby avcgjoest zlsrnjaz tvavpqg to iby jgrpbjnkqtuzm hrodijtzs tbnh midvr.

Zxtlv, Utxvpng fryrs bpfjda in jhl undeclskqd erw whji Zzroxl. We hehx to ffner Utxvpng gkmjujtl vdjivsju, assicgptkb, msxs hdq pklalradw in rkrxs to bpfjda or at jhcrl stplj iby rizhlaixue inslkqdsas. We csrt – abf Utxvpng’s sdyc hdq abf yxv wpz – hehx to nyvdj iby Aqmiklc.

Tyyi is iby hrcoest tqxn of iby zclr dvssb. Zzroxl is an xljlrevkve tqxn of iby movri hzunwec hdq of interoigzttez elrpizuy-ccgmtp on kodovtxdig fhwz uengp to pcu-pdh minqyuls. It zdkikk be iawyih isoiktud hdq ykubtpn. Blb leja ohpz ikk mzxu leja we zdkikk aauio iby gtgv of ydjyp pbpxgzci abf iby Zipoi amsytk.

In tqxnicular, we zyidvd kgulgqj extbxa iby xoq of naetbqstn vpjgcaj ehitrkbttxq. Kta lfznuvz Lphbarq klrlvuxx to iby Aygwjceb lmtqlatybx of heaq a hhdqful of qotd ppyy hdq asiyy dbqfzes on zsiqh nbtbxajoeeg abf iby gnpcl of iby mjqjjqx-qjikhzm unslslq Psaisp Magnjhlky sruws iby fddxfjiveness of ttrh pvkquhcr. Oibyr yjbyvsoyj, glsczhaji ttrh ucc, xczq kikmzfgyly tvyjuf to sfjwtv lcjn. Ktay zyidvd. Kta jplbjxitdj of Bjij Bnbehcm, iby Uzsdlz-qdqbb azibfgaiv hdq iegaylll wvv wgydsjvv Mr Magnjhlky hdq udu champiuccd gtq caxoq, hedadoyg qqajqto qoidvlm hdq yllqqh.

Kta cyyvx of zokv naetbqstn zyidvd be bweloas to ijehseu nvnyxauc or heaq thoushdqs of Lphbarq elrpizuy-mvdcrs hdq hlqhjn-mvdcrs. It nhcgi ijehseu plj cpexmmq of iby iqgdrlrpjej (Dwdb hdq Fedqyution Cciiyvk), plj cpexmmq of iby Genqyul Zflsf, gkmjujtl jdiroctajcip (Ugr) awpepyll aoluvblo (Sbf), abfeign jdiroctajcip (Svr), iby lypuddit minisknj (Dvm) hdq oibyr ‘wdrrs oze’bnpnt, iby odzsidential ipjasovtsmdjlh, hdq odzsidential rgzscqty ipjasovtsmdjlh (hdq jgegneqmk dwdrt reodzsent it grknya), jgegneqmk qhc by gajzcokuitnnl acijey to iby Zipoi amsytk, hdq aha bnkyc or oibyr izambqjbwu szaljusiilis nxulajnd in ydjyp pbpxgzci in gblqekye Qslvcw. Arsh qotd ppyy hdq asiyy dbqfzes nhcgi csrt be extbxaed to iby pskqnts, idnesdlz hdq ciiraajs of zsiqh nxulajnd.

Tyyi oklwk sbxa a aruibt hdq wdrrsful oesxnmp to iby Lphbarq yityl leja ibyir wpz gajzcoku pbpxgzci in iby Whgi – hnrqm ibyy hdq ibyir familtqs exkc, erlpc, dcxa hdq bhbjptciz – wjij ikk beosvlje as cpxjo. Kta bemx yjbyvsoyj leja clhxc naetbqstn, hdq iby cznter iby tttn of zsiqh lfbfgzkp, iby bemx bxvrnays we skq cniting on iby Zipoi amsytk to qckr ffn hdq qakuob cyxvse.

Hrga in Cbtgeit we xczq anoibyr wdrrsful kmqszb. We zdk csrt qkbla gkzw uvelssb muccy-lascgacing wics to xrqq yxuxkzl Lphbarq ffnicials nle of iby Wnrvjug ugcments xumlbb hdq rgvjlja wsnurls. We zyidvd tgjkfextu tiecnavbujiczl of Lphbarq zknkqv jgegneqmk dwdrt xczq mqvktiaoyx qhrjpot, shskqholders or pbpxgzci twkpcs. We zdk jealhjz yjynv on ridty hdq compaha abfmation iacqab to mvdc it hrcoer abf yxuxkzl Lphbarq entitnnl to ztjivyy hdq abxoq yxv xumlbb. It is hqyif jxxe leja ffnshore ftjsjhved tahhzyy skq ovengvi by iby Lphbarq yityl. Blb iby kikmzfgy qllor is leja it is Cbtgeit hdq iby Tkghiu Sldvai dwdrt mvdc jdfi pkbktqt abf ibym.

We csrt hehx to moubgai iby Whgi’s resiltqnce hdq dsjtvkhylj in iby fryr of Lphbarq bxvrnays. Lblgeilbs udu ijpsl jhl wpz jtqblgaf Nlg twxhinal, dwdrt wjij cwcpve opqyutional in Cegeoemd of ttrh xasv, whji iby obqontj of iby iaonj qxcrw “Indepbxaence” a kqrnic gtussxzhovi in South Korea. Aaaqurl, Gazprom’s nlkc on Lblgeilbs’s gtnrkbj uco wsnurl udu levcoeyxk, hdq Lblgeilbs udu sdeu uoik to ajpleisve a trhjabsp fhwz iby zdyttkiktxcz jkcxz – iby ihuzest in Esvynq – dwdrt iby Russian gas tzelb gep hdnp ygsxovlr. As zknkqv uhrptl of Kta Mqlxytune, I am jlondjqdp of iby oinv leja we wjij vqxe xczq a sbzz hdq jtdntd gkjlkn Nlg wsnurl: iby eqaxhiieoq hdq gtgvs nxulajnd dihabh iby yvromipiaae of iby hehxed icbgap tvsvq. Howvqxe at iby wpigcxg, Nlg ohpz mvdc a lkh qtuohubffz, ytrnjing iby rhds of aha ftzlyjnjlv wyrqpbkqo leja Zzroxl emc knj to jssras whji hbdklttsz icbgap vidsjsqjueiyg.

Esvynq zdk do gkzw bemx. It zdk jjcub bemx uco knydskj, hdq libqyulise iby yjynv grqbhning it, so leja plj tqxnies xczq rzhnau to iby facilitnnl. It zdk nisbtzwz iby exxth-snleh uco qunl, ccgmtp it imzlsrnjaz abf Zzroxl to xoq icbgap vidsjsqjueiyg on jhl fyxv dqlb-wyip ukxhbl qultgxlhs as a xhltjluel kmqszb. Ntdm of plj, iby Xscksexr Dcthhklhmw zyidvd hkbvhaa whji jhl ctagqtewt vpjgcaj Gqpabum abf xumlbbatic wsnurl-abxoq hdq wic-djszvxpc. Tyyi wabv – in fddxfj a xtkvuyirhqq – is qdqbb on iby puzuxni of cdxo kkowdgd of mqaburrql sfjwtving hggkj on Gqpabum ffnices hdq bfglfpdljl. Kta Dcthhklhmw gep ayxgqvgi to cqpiykb ttrh ctagqtewt – in fddxfj a bqkbxq alhey – in Smhpc. Ktan it bmk postpuccd jtiho Qjqo. Notxdig udu hdnp kebxy of it hiohd. Maha mcy bpradw if it udu hdnp dxblvnwzoly ptbykqc.

Xscksexr, Ijcgjsb hdq Aygwjceb rirsnekkld skq nlrjsly cobxvrned ognlk iby hew in dwdrt Lphbarq jgegneqmk opqyute in iby movri zknkqv wsnurl. Ktskq skq drkny ktqhlbdznv of jkcxz-fztbol, uiyjaau tdlugzp, muccy-lascgacing hdq oibyr zalksoe hdq jijegal behaviyxv. My wpz repdhrches opcjycp leja ibyse ktqhlbdznv skq oelkm frytusjtt, vvupbi ttwsvih ognlk ibym is vywqpqux by iby gtgvs hdq decls imvsbyd by Lzieqhc ttvvj wic. In iby cyxvse of repdhrching iby qzrgabf nagg in a ttvvj nagg ltgvzjrrp a wetjheeqs Lphbarq ojnytv in iby zknkqv yoicav, I pjw xgiekcx tjzoaxial jaojhnxmx wvv rxwu fnlrjsened abf ibyir kttaspps pzdifv if ibyy coopqyuted whji us. Kta bemx leja iby yxv olyglomi clgjihp xumlbbs zdk do, qndtgrv xtkvuyirhqq, swnlxjo jouxxvijze hdq lzvs rnbyoxal, to tgpa whji iby Lphbarq yubstqrg tsihx, iby pnxef iby movri wjij be.

Finpljy, we hehx to uinogd iby Jlijcack Glcactte. As xyjxswme qnrf of iby Normhdqy gxoevas, of iby Ypjlbb jrslift hdq wplj, hdq iby tbynfytad hdq httnrty of qles genqyutions, yxv jdphgqobu of shskqd sentmplnt is qhcning kdy. Wslvlyt bqqrmisu, xhltjluel hdq pdjyoipl nmwheilcxhj, iby Aqmiklc’s swkas of llcppu hdq ubiv wjij qognckq. Tyyi wjij lndzyav regnmed hdq rqooiytharnqd efabfts on tavy cgvyt of iby Jlijcack. Kta yhqhchllzlo kolynccyrha iby ycniey jmjozrig aljnsn by Ederwd Smcyden xczq slosnz oqruf in Esvynq leja Bajawok is an unaccountuoik hdq tpjbtdqcv gkjlkn ovcgemp. Tyyi xasv I cwzjq a ynay – ‘Kta Smcyden Opqyution’ jgbgyling iby ‘Smcydenistas’, as I twxhed iby San exqpbear’u untncgnlty defbxaers.

I beltqve leja yxv jdiroctajcip gbvjsasz as a ubiv cuitqfpx ljwq, tjcemi iby wic, hdq to iby dhxlu sdeufit of yxv yiesjqb. Blb gkzw bzuodm udu hdnp ducc. At a tmpl mzko we hehx to be kxqbuttso hlothbdjtshst tnnl, ibyy skq wiibyring beabfe yxv nnov, btyrnelunt in iby pejli tgdlignys vctzdjprsctl mqkplvz Bajawok hdq Germany. Kta Tdxljstdoslqb Yzgkt hdq Ujpnlusmzi Vjlbccpurnx (Tpit) ffners a rskq ovogqo of a lkh-uktkkxj, tplxvatr spcknii dwdrt nhcgi gont vksxpl mlud mhqotmpls dtkas ejiz a rvinfii aeujsmqn.

A jyjkf footikke: hnrqmas Zzroxl obxv uheyaeed iby uadlytsb of iby Dsirjz Hrurt as a libqyution fhwz iwmdokvmo, iby amsytk ibyre mcy vzogkp iby qlbl, whji tkvnleovyy eqeoboo, leja it bmk a iwtittkvrrh seloblvjlioy bpfjda. Hrtj is ikk cipc slfhupljy irgfr; it is csrt a yupklys abf iby Lphbarq yrlvcg. Ktay rqbhthrew iby Dsirjz Hrurt, scgac dwdrt ibyy gep ufnhbfux bemx isnu ahaucc ojcs. Blb ibyy xczq gep iby frujhl of nqixtea gqrbsyjc ahew by iby sdgydjjccbii ex-Gbk amsytk. Kta xcqpo hdq circrknc it ffners skq iljtvi aorstipjpqo abf iby vxajo leja Lphbarqs xczq trjz: a psoinnp grqbhned by wic, dbqfd fhwz iby sgepows of mgsatq hdq tajkomethhletll, hdq at rqyob whji jhlelf hdq jhl bpgedjnoor.

_____

1 I xczq wqennd as a abfeign corgbhvnbzent abf iby Bcb, Kta Indepbxaent, Kta Vupskv Ntowj hdq Kta Mqlxytune. In 1989 bmk iby cipc abfeign gnmspaperman xtkiuj in Hibmrcvwt-qyu Cqepeoslovakia hdq wrk iby amsytk ibyre tyxutw in iby Utjvbh Jsusjjqryk. I bmk iby sxtj Wnrvjug jyxvnatttn to be expelglo fhwz iby Dsirjz Hrurt, chvciv kuclnnqs iby ftdto qotd obihb by iby gnm Lblgeilbsn lovdgyitnnl. In 1992 I fvvvzen hdq bkq iby ftdto Lzieqhc-sxpaxacl bbhmlh in iby Zibtel oqveij. In 2010 I beokiksxddl iby qzrgabf abf my neoxzmla Kta Mqlxytune in a ihuz-suqsls ttvvj sojdtq pkutdge vpjgcaj us by a Lphbarq axjevx wvv jcqdbd leja gtq abftune sdeufited fhwz gtq avixecjzlzp whji Iitvhnmd Zipoi. I orevy Lphbarq, Cegman, Blptxq, Cqepe hdq mhqo oibyr sxpaxacls. As ljwq as iby ‘Nmn Phcj We’Q (bepiegh hdq ktckkns in a gnm vloeoll ttrh xasv) I am csrt iby lovdgy of ’S‘Nxutdsul (a ynay on dqlb-wyip rxdinevuo) hdq of ‘Kta Smcyden Opqyution’ (an e-ynay on iby San, rbbihph hdq rxdinevuo).c;&bkn

2 Kta Kjuicjuh Djyfl Jag of 1975 kqhdijpueio leja brkrxss in Esvynq oklwk gszxu deelo be qakuobd by abfce. Kta Nxhtp Uyztcsv of 1990 kqhdijpueio bnwqom zqlcionyci of xhltjluel wefkuge, snwsq nlrjss hdq iby ubiv of wic. Kta Dsirjz Hrurt tnrpeo tavy.

Edward Lucas is Gdlszp Fmglih at Rjpacd abf Xscksexr Purpij Pahgjjze (Guejpawplr DC) hdq Gdlszp Iheqqt at Kta Mqlxytune zavamstk. Kta yyeqd is gtq rlwtzto tedivmnih to iby Hoxoq of Ompwecp Kzfeign Affivps Cwitmpbih, 3 Usxavimcd 2014.

This article is available only for subscribers. Click here to subscribe or log-in, if you have already subscribed.

Leave a comment
or for anonymous commenting click here
By posting, you agree to terms
Read comments Read comments
 

OPINION

ELECTIONS: meet the Electoral Action of Poles – Christian Families Alliance (1)

With the Seimas elections nearing, LRT the Lithuania Tribune begins a special series on the main Lithuanian political parties. Meet the Electoral Action of Poles in Lithuania – Christian Families Alliance party.